How JustAnswer Works:
  • Ask an Expert
    Experts are full of valuable knowledge and are ready to help with any question. Credentials confirmed by a Fortune 500 verification firm.
  • Get a Professional Answer
    Via email, text message, or notification as you wait on our site.
    Ask follow up questions if you need to.
  • 100% Satisfaction Guarantee
    Rate the answer you receive.
Ask DrJackiePhD Your Own Question
DrJackiePhD, Doctor
Category: Relationship
Satisfied Customers: 364
Experience:  I have been doing research in relational/interpersonal communication since 1998. My Ph.D. is in interpersonal communication.
Type Your Relationship Question Here...
DrJackiePhD is online now
A new question is answered every 9 seconds

I've been married months, and every month has been

Customer Question

I've been married for 7 months, and every month has been difficult. There were signs I didn't pay attention to before marriage, and since our wedding night it has been a series of issues that have left me disconnected. He's terribly insecure and suspicious, and I'm the opposite. I've recently realized that I don't want to, nor do I like being married. I feel suffocated, unhappy and wondering why each time I say I've had enough, he becomes the very nice, giving person I thought he was. It doesn't last long, then I say it again: same cycle. I feel like he's a Jeckyl and Hyde personality who comes up with negativity about me, stews on it all day, and attacks. I'm often blindsided by this, and I feel like my life is busy and stressful enough that I just want out. I'm 47, twice divorced, single mom of 2, business owner, just finishing a doctorate, and my plate is overflowing. I've come to realize that our life goals will only happen if I make it happen. He works a job, contributes about 10% to the home, but often he is guilting about how my money is my money and his is his. He insists I'm hiding something, but in fact 100% of my earnings go into the home (he has access to our joint account, I have no access to his). I understand that his job doesn't pay as much, and the home we live in was mine long before we met. There have been many nights he's had one too many to drink and either ignored me, insulted me in front of others, or blindsided me with some sort of meanness. I feel numb in these situations, and find I don't respond to his negativity (I have a daughter at home). But I just feel tired, fed up and I want out. Now that I feel this way, he's the decent version of himself and it's making me feel crazy!
Submitted: 1 year ago.
Category: Relationship
Expert:  DrJackiePhD replied 1 year ago.


I'm Dr. Jackie, an interpersonal communication researcher/professor and relationship expert. First, congrats on accomplishing so much in your life! And you seem very driven to continue on--that is terrific! Second, I'm so sorry to hear how difficult this marriage has been. You don't say anything that I can tell with regard to how you two met or how he was when you dated or what made you decide to marry him. So I am wondering if he was Dr. Jeckyl the entire time you dated, and I'm guessing it was a very short courtship. Mr. Hyde couldn't possibly hide for long.

It sounds like it is the typical "Run until I Catch You Game." That is, like you have indicated, when he senses you are going away or physically and emotionally are distanced from him, he will metaphorically run hard to try to win you back. Of course, he has to be sweet and nice to win you back. Once he "has" you, he doesn't have to "try anymore" because you are there. And you are absolutely right--the cycle continues and continues.

It's very sad, but this is not uncommon, at least to some degree. In many relationships, once one party "has" the other, albeit it an engagement, marriage, moving in, or some other more "permanent" establishment in the relationship, often the person who had to try harder initially to "win the other person over" feels like they can finally "relax." Unfortunately, "relaxing" in that person's mind can be twisted in that they give up all strategies of "winning the other person over," not even understanding or realizing that one needs to actually employ the same strategies to MAINTAIN the relationship.

I can give you a bibliography of references on relationship maintenance since I was blessed to have some of the top relationship scholars in the field actually teach my Ph.D. classes. Or if you would prefer to talk on the phone or Skype, I'll send you that information once I am finished here.

But for now, I'm not seeing a direct question, but I'm guessing you want some suggestions or even recommendations on what to do. If you really want to try to save your marriage, then he needs to recognize what he is doing and fix it. There is about a 1% chance statistically of him doing this on his own. Almost always change occurs through an external force, such as a near death experience, a tragedy, and/or some type of intervention. Counseling/therapy can be this intervention. But he has to acknowledge that he has a problem and secondly be willing to do something about it. And being willing means not merely saying he will change--how many dieters have said that? But until they pay for/sign up for a plan, that change never happens. It is the same with relationship change. A trained therapist/counselor can help but only if he sees he has a problem and want to change.

I hope this has been helpful. Again, I will send you my contact information should you decide that you would like to go that route. And please let me know what you think or if any of my assumptions were wrong.

Take good care,

--Dr. Jackie

Customer: replied 1 year ago.
Dr. Jackie,
Your assumption is correct. Short courtship, pressure and me caving in. I didn't ask a question apparently. Number one I want to know if me feeling unsteady or crazy as I put it, is the result of his type of behavior. And, as I've said, I don't like being married, but would marriage counseling be recommended since I really just want out? I'm willing to seek help for myself to identify my issues and why I've married twice quickly.
Expert:  DrJackiePhD replied 1 year ago.

Hi again,

To answer the second question, I'm sorry I missed the fact that you said clearly that you want out. Since that seems to be the case, I don't think marriage counseling is necessary. Like you already mentioned, getting yourself healthy and focused on what you really want from a relationship is what I recommend. And of course, this would be you only. To go back to the first question, this is more difficult to answer without really having sat down and talked with your husband let alone you. So I would hate to assign a false cause and effect evaluation on such a brief interaction between us. I think his back and forth, running til he catches you then turning into Mr. Hyde, you running away, then him turning nice, cycle repeat, etc. certainly has affected you negatively. I don't think that you would be human if you were NOT affected. But also like you indicated, there may be events in your past that have had such an impact on your that you have a need to act quickly or impulsively. I don't know if "impulsively" is correct, but "quickly" for sure. There may be insecurities caused by someone significant in your life who deeply hurt you and so now you have this "need" to "hang on" to someone who seems to really love you because you have this need to "keep him" before he leaves?

These last few thoughts are all educated guesses or hypotheses, and again, I think you may be able to answer #1 as you work with a therapist/counselor face-to-face and explore these issues in depth with you.

I hope that helps. I'm willing to talk on the phone or Skype if you think that would be helpful.

Take good care,

--Dr. Jackie

Related Relationship Questions