How JustAnswer Works:
  • Ask an Expert
    Experts are full of valuable knowledge and are ready to help with any question. Credentials confirmed by a Fortune 500 verification firm.
  • Get a Professional Answer
    Via email, text message, or notification as you wait on our site. Ask follow up questions if you need to.
  • 100% Satisfaction Guarantee
    Rate the answer you receive.
Ask KimberlyF Your Own Question
KimberlyF, Longtime Relationship Expert
Category: Relationship
Satisfied Customers: 750
Experience:  Relationship expert for almost three years with
Type Your Relationship Question Here...
KimberlyF is online now
A new question is answered every 9 seconds

hi there, Im 25, have had a best friend for 5 years, shes

This answer was rated:

hi there,
Im 25, have had a best friend for 5 years, she's been very good to me, her brother moved back to town and started coming around, and we started dating and didnt tell anyone for awile (he's 40) because he had to figure things out with his children's mother (they arn't married) they Do have 9 kids together, but she has served him papers, and just been down right horrible to him for YEARS, so we finally came out about our relationship, now, everyone wants to be involeved on how we date and what we should and shouldnt do- they practically forced me to break up with him. i like him. alot. but havent had a chance to even focus on OUr relationship because of all the "drama", now; my bestfriend has turned on me, has been saying horrible things about me. and i just cant take it anymore. i broke up with him friday nite, against my heart, because of everyone elses opionins.... what should i do??? i can give plently more details- but thats just the jist


A true friend wouldn't turn on you for dating their brother and wanting a relationship without the family being involved and if she did indeed turn on you then she really wasn't a friend and you should verbalize that to her. I think you should follow your heart and keep your relationship private aside from his family but you need to also talk to the friend and tell her it's unfair how she is treating you after you have been friends for so long and that she should know you better than that. It's unfair for them to interfere in your relationship since you are both adults and can very well handle your own relationship. Everyone is entitled to their own opinion but they should keep it to themselves and your boyfriend should tell them that, he is 40 years old and doesn't owe them any explanation about your relationship and where it's going.


I would call him and apologize and be honest about how his family pressured you and pushed you to break up with him, tell him that you care about him and want him to be with you no matter how his family feels about it. Tell him you want to see where the relationship can go. Life is too short to live it according to how everyone else wants you to live it or else you would be miserable and alone. I would carry on the relationship where it left off and not worry about what other say. If you have anything to add please just click the reply button.

Customer: replied 8 years ago.
what about the 9 kids? their (him and the mother) relationship has been over for 2 years,it is still a bit rocky...and i have told him that its going to take time to let things settle down in their house-(he doesnt live there- but you know what i mean)
i hate that the sister says to me that I AM messing the kids up, and "think of the kids" and making me feel really guilty for enjoying myself with him I know in my heart families split, but that doesnt change how he is a father to those children. i make sure he spends time with them, i dont want to mess the children up, but know if he sets boundries with the mother that their family will be fine. but even then- this is still really new (4months) and its alot all at once and i cant figure out how to respond to any of it because its all very new to me. and things just keep coming up and there has been no time to deal with the first thing.


Take the relationship slower so that you both can work out the issues at hand but his sister cannot expect him to be alone and lonely just because the mother of his children and him cannot get along that isn't very fair. It's not like the two of you have to rush the relationship maybe if you gave them time to adjust and see that you are indeed encouraging him to see his children then they may be more accepting of the relationship. The first thing you should do is talk to the ex and ask him to try again, second thing you do is set some ground rules as to how much the family knows about the relationship and what goes on in it, thirdly do not mention your relationship to his children it may be too much for them to handle right now give it some time for it to sink in that their mother and father will no longer be together and it's best for everyone involved, fourth talk to the friend and tell her to please just give you a chance and if it harms the children in any way you will step back and give him time.


Also allow him to be there for his children no matter what even if you had something planned and something comes up with the children as long as it doesn't happen too often then allow him to be there whenever they need him then they will see that you are not a threat and aren't trying to take their father from them. Sometimes children act more mature than adults do and the child may surprise you and take to you very easily if they can see that you are with them not against them, if they get even the littlest hint that you are a threat they will turn on you and never give you a chance. Also you have to decide if you are truly ready to take this on with everything that has already happened is this too much too soon?

KimberlyF and other Relationship Specialists are ready to help you