I am a fan of Panasonic. They don't spice up the gimmicks and make them incompatible with other gear. They tend to be reliable most of the time, they're cost effective, and consistent.Click here
. This one says Hulu, but not Netflix, so be sure to ask the sales guy.
Another brand that I am loyal to, but they cost a bit more is the LG players. I don't recall seeing more than 2 of them come through this site. Click here
. It's good if you can establish a hard wired connection to your router, but has no wifi.
And this one is a couple of steps up from what you have. It costs a bit more, but it's on sale right now. Click here
. It's built with better parts, so it is more reliable. It has wifi.
Let me know if you have any questions about these players, or if you like one but it's out of your price range. I'll try to find a similar one for cheaper.
I have learned that Best Buy can only warranty your player. Tell them you wish to switch to a different player, and they may exchange it for you, if you have the packaging.