How JustAnswer Works:
  • Ask an Expert
    Experts are full of valuable knowledge and are ready to help with any question. Credentials confirmed by a Fortune 500 verification firm.
  • Get a Professional Answer
    Via email, text message, or notification as you wait on our site.
    Ask follow up questions if you need to.
  • 100% Satisfaction Guarantee
    Rate the answer you receive.
Ask Ray Your Own Question
Ray, Lawyer
Category: Real Estate Law
Satisfied Customers: 41073
Experience:  Texas Attorney for 30 years dealing in real estate
Type Your Real Estate Law Question Here...
Ray is online now
A new question is answered every 9 seconds

I recently received a loan modification. My lender is OCWEN.

Customer Question

I recently received a loan modification. My lender is OCWEN. My original loan balance was 676k. They lowered my principle to 511,366 by doing a deferred amount if I stay current for 3 years or if I sell the home and payoff the current balance than the amount of 163366 will be forgiven. That also put an appreciation clause in the contract that gives them 25% of the proceeds from the sale. I want to know if this is something that you have heard of before. Thank you
Submitted: 2 years ago.
Category: Real Estate Law
Expert:  Ray replied 2 years ago.
Hi and welcome to JA. I am Ray and will be the expert helping you today.
Yes this is currently permitted under California law and has become pretty standard in such a situation involving loan modification.
Here is the law for reference.
SECTION 1***-***-****.069
1917.060. The relationship of the borrower and the lender, as to a
shared appreciation loan, is that of debtor and creditor and shall
not be, or be construed to be, a joint venture, equity venture,
partnership, or other relationship.
1917.061. Any waiver of any right of a borrower under the
provisions of this chapter shall be void and unenforceable.
1917.062. (a) Notwithstanding Section 711, a provision in a shared
appreciation loan (not including the refinancing obligation)
permitting the lender to accelerate the maturity date of the
principal and accrued interest on the loan upon a sale or other
transfer of the property, as specified in subdivision (e) of Section
1917.031, shall be valid and enforceable against the borrower, except
as may be precluded by Section 2924.6.
(b) The Legislature finds and declares that potential exposure to
liability for enforcement of a "due-on-sale" clause consistent with
Section 711, as interpreted by the courts, makes use of such a
provision impractical. Moreover, the additional risks to the lender
inherent in shared appreciation financing are greater with longer
loan terms (which are more desirable from the standpoint of housing
affordability), but this risk is reduced with an enforceable
"due-on-sale" clause. Therefore, in order to facilitate shared
appreciation financing, it is necessary to establish the exception
specified in subdivision (a).
1917.063. This chapter facilitates the making of shared
appreciation financing in this state which conforms to the provisions
of this chapter. The terms and conditions of any shared appreciation
loan made pursuant to this chapter shall be consistent with this
chapter. This chapter does not, however, apply to or limit shared
appreciation financing of real property of a type specified in
Section 1917.030 that is made pursuant to other provisions of law, or
which is not otherwise unlawful. Nothing in this chapter shall be
construed to in any way affect shared appreciation financing of
commercial property or residential property not meeting the criteria
specified in Section 1917.030.
Nothing in this chapter precludes a pension fund specified in
Section 1917.030 from providing shared appreciation financing
pursuant to Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 1917.110) or any other
provision of law, or which is not otherwise unlawful.
1917.064. A shared appreciation loan shall not be subject to any
provision of this code or the Financial Code which limits the
interest rate or change of interest rate of variable, adjustable, or
renegotiable interest instruments, or which requires particular
language or provisions in security instruments securing variable,
adjustable, or renegotiable rate obligations or in evidences of such
This section is declaratory of existing law.
1917.065. The lien of a deed of trust securing a shared
appreciation loan shall include and secure the principal amount of
the shared appreciation loan, and all interest, whether accrued or to
be accrued, including all amounts of contingent deferred interest.
1917.066. The lien of a shared appreciation loan, including the
principal amount and all interest, whether accrued or to be accrued,
and all amounts of contingent deferred interest, shall attach from
the time of the recordation of the deed of trust securing the loan,
and the lien, including the lien of the interest accrued or to be
accrued and of the contingent deferred interest, shall have priority
over any other lien or encumbrance affecting the property secured by
the shared appreciation instrument which is recorded after the time
of recordation of the shared appreciation instrument. However,
nothing in this section or Section 1917.165 shall preclude a junior
lien or encumbrance subordinate to the obligation of the shared
appreciation loan.
1917.067. Lenders shall be exempt from the usury provisions of
Article XV of the California Constitution with respect to shared
appreciation loans made pursuant to this chapter.
This section is declaratory of existing law.
1917.068. The qualification requirements of Sections 25110, 25120,
and 25130 of the Corporations Code shall not apply to a shared
appreciation loan, provided (1) the loan obligation is evidenced by
one promissory note secured by a deed of trust which is not one of a
series of notes secured by interests in the same real property and
(2) the loan obligation is not evidenced by fractional undivided
interests in one promissory note secured by interests in the same
real property.
1917.069. The aggregate amount of any fee charged to the borrower
for processing an application and preparing any necessary documents
in connection with originating a shared appreciation loan shall not
exceed the reasonable cost of providing the service. No prepaid
interest shall be charged to the borrower, but nothing in this
chapter shall preclude a lender from requiring a fee for providing
commitments for shared appreciation loans to builders or others who
will not be the ultimate borrower.
It is legal for them to include this as part of terms of the loan modification.
I appreciate the chance to help you today.Please let me know if you have more follow up.Thanks again.
Expert:  Ray replied 2 years ago.
More about how a SAM shared appreciation mortgage works in California.
Thanks again for the chance to help today.
Customer: replied 2 years ago.
So does that mean they get 25% of anything I sell my home for or just on the deffered amount
Expert:  Ray replied 2 years ago.
A shared appreciation mortgage or SAM is a mortgage in which the lender agrees as part of the loan to accept some or all payment in the form of a share of the increase in value (the appreciation) of the property.Unless there is appreciation here you do not pay.
Say your home at refinance is valued at $100,000. After three years, you decide to move; your home has appreciated by $9,273. In a 50% revenue-sharing arrangement, you'd owe the lender half that -- $4,637 -- plus, of course, the remaining unpaid balance of your loan
Does that clarify, this is new relatively new to California but it a way banks try to recoup funds if they agree to refinance and the house grows in value.
More here skip down the page to shared appreciation towards the bottom.This lays it out pretty clearly.
Expert:  Ray replied 2 years ago.
The lender only gets a piece of the appreciation, if house does not appreciate they only get the loan pay off back.Its a way to lower your payments but if real estate goes up they are going to get a piece of it.They are betting it goes up here in California and it probably will.It also prevents more foreclosures so it is a win/win for both of you.
Thanks again for letting me assist you today.
JA will email you our chat with references once you positive rate.Thanks again.
Customer: replied 2 years ago.
Ok so if my new principle balance is 511366 and I sell for 700k the profit would be approx. 188k they would receive 25% of that amount
Expert:  Ray replied 2 years ago.
Yes thats correct they share in the profits this amount.It is a means for them to offer below market refinancing here, they get a piece a pretty good piece if it goes up in value.
Thanks for letting me clarify this for you.
Good luck with all of this, maybe it will go up in the future and you can make some money here even if they get a piece of it.

Related Real Estate Law Questions