How JustAnswer Works:
  • Ask an Expert
    Experts are full of valuable knowledge and are ready to help with any question. Credentials confirmed by a Fortune 500 verification firm.
  • Get a Professional Answer
    Via email, text message, or notification as you wait on our site.
    Ask follow up questions if you need to.
  • 100% Satisfaction Guarantee
    Rate the answer you receive.
Ask Sally G. Your Own Question
Sally G.
Sally G., Dog Training Consultant
Category: Dog
Satisfied Customers: 9517
Experience:  Service/assistance dog training/ behavior /obedience/Therapy dog Evaluator/AKC Evaluator
Type Your Dog Question Here...
Sally G. is online now
A new question is answered every 9 seconds

My dog refuses to go the bathroom outside. Well be outside

Resolved Question:

My dog refuses to go the bathroom outside. We'll be outside for an hour and she won't go. Then we come back in and she goes on the carpet immediately. What can I do?
Submitted: 7 years ago.
Category: Dog
Expert:  Sally G. replied 7 years ago.



How old is she?


what is the breed?


Where did she come from? (store, kennel etc.)


At what age did you get her?


What do you do when you find the accident?


Beside taking her out every half hour and the paper towel stuff what have you tried?

Customer: replied 7 years ago.
We got both of them from somebody on We were told that she and her brother were found in duffel bag with a third dog that had passed away in the bag. Suppossedly they are 4-5 months old. But the person we got them from refuses to give us thier paperwork and won't tell us who the vet is where she took them to. Now she isn't anwsering our calls. So we don't know how much is true and what is not true. We believe she is half yorkshire terrier and half chihahua. We just got her two weeks ago. That's about it as far as what we're tried. We tried crate training her but she doesn't mind going in her crate and her crate is not big enough for her to avoid the mess. When we find the accident we just clean it and try to get the scent off the carpet. If we catch her in the act we say NO firmly and then carry her outside immediately.
Expert:  Sally G. replied 7 years ago.

Thank you for that information. Since she came from a place you don't know anything about it is possible that they ruined her for potty training. Unbelievable but true , some people still think that if a dog messes in the house then you should put the nose in it and holler at the dog. Dogs do not learn anything from this other than to be afraid to eliminate in front of people.


It has not been long since you have had her that long so it is going to take time to build a trust with her. She may be a more submissive dog than the brother and may frighten easily in certain situations , all depending on how she was previously treated.


What I would do is to continue to crate her to spare your home when she cannot be watched. When you are home with her tether her to you so she must follow you around and you can keep a very close eye on her. If she squats do what you have been doing, however when she is eliminating put a command to it. Something like Go potty and continue saying that even as she is eliminating until she stops. Then praise and give a special treat. It can be a piece of hot dog, or a special dog type treat that she will only get at this time to further encourage her to want to go outside. Outside with you and with the command will begin to equal something good for her.


It may take some time so be patient and try not to get angry in front of her. I would also start doing some positive obedience training with her to further your bond. I am going to direct you to a site for this. The training tools are not expensive, maybe three dollars and whatever treats you want to use.



` Clicker training

video, shows how clicker training is done

Sally G. and other Dog Specialists are ready to help you