Ob-Gyn questions? Ask a gynecologist online.
The failure rated of condoms is 2 percent for perfect use. It sounds like you used the condom correctly. Pregnancy does not occur with semen on a females fingers and has nothing to do with urinating before using the condom. The odds are 2% when used perfectly. You can increase the effectiveness of the method by not ejaculating in the condom which you did, or using spermicidal foam.