Ask a Lawyer and Get Answers to Your Legal Questions
I think if you are willing to do the ownership transfer they may be willing to work with you. Alternatively, you could threaten to report the owner you gave her to to the humane society or any applicable government agency so that she can facilitate the return. A more expensive route would be filing a breach of contract claim but it would be tougher to prove that this was a contract not a gift.
Thanks for signing up for our service. If you still need assistance, I'm here to help. If not, could you kindly "accept" the answer and rate it so that I can be credited and can close it out?