How JustAnswer Works:
  • Ask an Expert
    Experts are full of valuable knowledge and are ready to help with any question. Credentials confirmed by a Fortune 500 verification firm.
  • Get a Professional Answer
    Via email, text message, or notification as you wait on our site.
    Ask follow up questions if you need to.
  • 100% Satisfaction Guarantee
    Rate the answer you receive.
Ask John Legal Your Own Question
John Legal
John Legal, Attorney
Category: Legal
Satisfied Customers: 4631
Experience:  Over 15 years legal experience.
Type Your Legal Question Here...
John Legal is online now
A new question is answered every 9 seconds

I listed a guitar on ebay(no refunds or exchanges), buyer won

This answer was rated:

I listed a guitar on ebay(no refunds or exchanges), buyer won auction, then says doesnt want to pay without knowing more about the product. I complied. He asked for extra photos, he asks questions, we confirm the authenticity of product parts, some turned out non-original. He deducts amount from winning auction price and made me an offer ($5500) and I took it. He also suggested we deal outside of ebay so that i would save on ebay fees. We cancelled the ebay transaction and dealt outside of ebay. He sent check, it cleared, I fedex the product with tracking. He recieved product and is unhappy. I will not refund or take product back. He is threatening to sue on the basis of "item not as described". Buyer is in Connneticutt, I am in CA. Do I need to worry? Does he have a case? He's claiming that I knowingly sold him a repaired-used-to-be-broken guitar that has reduced value. I did not know anything of this repair he is claming.
Welcome! Thank you for your question.

Essentially he is claiming that you breached your contract to supply him the guitar as described in your conversations and with photos. So long as you supplied him a guitar as you described and did not represent or hid anything that was material then you would not be in breach of contract.

With all that said, you do have two issues: First, since the contract is not fully in writing most of the agreement will be based on oral testimony with you saying one thing and him saying another. It will be up to the court to sort out who to believe.

The second issue is that it is possible that the court in Connecticut would take personal jurisdiction over you since you communicated over the phone, by email and shipped the product to the buyer in Connecticut. If the court takes jurisdiction over you then you will have to defend the lawsuit in Connecticut. This would be very time consuming and expensive from CA. The jurisdiction is obtained under the long arm personal jurisdiction statute. If you are sued then you need to hire an attorney in Connecticut to challenge the suit based on lack of jurisdiction. If you appear yourself then you will likely waive any jurisdiction objection.

I cannot provide you with legal advise. I have provided you with information about the law related to your question. My answer, and any information that you find online, should not take the place of having a consultation with a lawyer in your area to advise you regarding your specific issues.

Please show your appreciation for my candid, accurate information by clicking VERY INFORMATIVE, OR the OR and positive feedback. You should only rate me if you are satisfied with the information I provided you. If you cannot rate me GREAT please do not rate. Give me a chance to make it right by clicking REPLY TO EXPERT.

I appreciate your question and repeat customers. You can request me by beginning your question with "Dear XXXXX..."

Thank you,


John Legal and 3 other Legal Specialists are ready to help you