How JustAnswer Works:
  • Ask an Expert
    Experts are full of valuable knowledge and are ready to help with any question. Credentials confirmed by a Fortune 500 verification firm.
  • Get a Professional Answer
    Via email, text message, or notification as you wait on our site. Ask follow up questions if you need to.
  • 100% Satisfaction Guarantee
    Rate the answer you receive.
Ask Legalease Your Own Question
Legalease, Lawyer
Category: Family Law
Satisfied Customers: 16379
Experience:  13 years experience, divorce & custody issues, protective orders, child abuse issues
Type Your Family Law Question Here...
Legalease is online now
A new question is answered every 9 seconds

Ive been served a rule nisi asking for me to show just cause

Resolved Question:

I've been served a rule nisi asking for me to show just cause why ex husband's request for relief should not be granted. I have two questions. One, is this asking me to show cause about legal fees or everything he asked for in the custody suit? Two, how do I respond to this?
Submitted: 6 years ago.
Category: Family Law
Expert:  Legalease replied 6 years ago.

Hello. Can I ask a few questions ?


1. Ages of child(ren)?


2. Does he have primary custody or do you? It sounds as if he does, but I just want to be certain. If he has physical custody, do you have any percentage of legal custody (to participate in school, medical decisions, etc?)


3. How many years have you been divorced?


4. Can I ask you exactly what relief he is seeking and why?



Customer: replied 6 years ago.
14, 11.

It is actually my wife's ex. But they had joint with her primary until March when the boys filed affidavits saying they wanted to live with their dad. My wife was to have counseling sessions as the kids wouldn't see her after they filed the affidavits. Right now there is a temp order, her ex and the kids refused to see her for 5 months. Went to court in August, judge was upset. Wife now seeing them in counseling with joint custody but he has ultimate say if no agreement can be reached.

She has been divorced 9 years.

That is one of the questions, in his original filing he asked for legal fees to be paid and essentially that they live with him primary with joint custody. So I'm not sure if the relief is the legal definition of how custody would be allotted or his legal fees.
Expert:  Legalease replied 6 years ago.

Hello. First, she should telephone the family court -- clerk's office for civil / family court business and ask someone there if the court expects that your wife should file a written response to this nisi request or if the court simply expects her to appear and oppose the requests that he is making to the court (courts do this differently -- even two courts in the same county -- one may want a written response, the other just an appearance at the hearing -- it all depends upon what the chief judge at that particular court wants filed in each case). If you need to prepare a written response as well as appear at the hearing, your written response to this should be simple and to the point -- because the order nisi is really an order for her to appear and show just cause (which means testimony). It should be formatted at the top (court name, plaintiff v defendant, case number) just as prior paperwork in this case has been set up. Then after it is set up, you should center text a title "Answer to Plaintiff's Nisi Request to Show Just Cause"

and then a short paragraph under that stating something like "Now comes the Defendant and states that she will appear at the hearing to show just cause and counters Plaintiff's allegations herein and will further counter Plaintiff's allegations at the hearing, as follows:" , then start a new paragraph in numbered paragraph format, you need to counter each charge/allegation or request made by the Plaintiff (for example: 1. Plaintiff requests that Defendant pay Plaintiff's legal fees. Defendant objects to this request and states that Plaintiff's legal fees would not be so high or would be non-existent if Plaintiff did not bring so many frivolous action before the court in an attempt to interfere with Defendant's relationship with her children, 2......(then set out the next request and your wife's objection to it), 3. etc etc. Obviously, you and she need to sit down and write these responses out to each of the items he is requesting (if it is custody, and she wants custody returned to her, she should give a brief statement to that effect and state why -- but be brief). If you miss something in the written answer you can still bring it up at the hearing on these matters, but it is good to touch upon them if you can. Then she signs it at the bottom and puts a paragraph underneath that stating that "I have served the Plaintiff with a copy of this Response this ___ day of October, 2010 via US Mail (or in hand if she delivers it personally). She then takes/sends an original to the court (clerk's office) prior to the court date -- some courts will tell you that you should simply bring it with you on the court date and give it to the judge that day - and the judge may simply want to hear the testimony (if you do that, then do not give the ex a copy until just before she walks into the hearing, either). If the clerk's office office takes the response and files it, then she should mail a copy to the ex and keep a copy so she can use it as her "cue card" in court. I wish that I could write this up for you, but it is against our site rules for me to do that -- however, I think I gave you enough of a blueprint to help her write this up herself if she does need to file a written response.




Please press the GREEN ACCEPT BUTTON so I will be paid for my time. I am not paid a paycheck and Just Answer does not pay me for answering this question until you press ACCEPT when you are finished reviewing the answer. This website is a great resource for customers who could not otherwise afford to speak with an attorney and we will not be able to continue if customers who use our services do not press the ACCEPT button when they are finished. Sort of like paying it forward. THANK YOU !!

Legalease and other Family Law Specialists are ready to help you