How JustAnswer Works:
  • Ask an Expert
    Experts are full of valuable knowledge and are ready to help with any question. Credentials confirmed by a Fortune 500 verification firm.
  • Get a Professional Answer
    Via email, text message, or notification as you wait on our site. Ask follow up questions if you need to.
  • 100% Satisfaction Guarantee
    Rate the answer you receive.
Ask Samuel II Your Own Question
Samuel II
Samuel II, Attorney at Law
Category: Criminal Law
Satisfied Customers: 27011
Experience:  Handle criminal matters in both state and federal courts.
Type Your Criminal Law Question Here...
Samuel II is online now
A new question is answered every 9 seconds

My son is in a federal prison in California. He has been doing

This answer was rated:

My son is in a federal prison in California. He has been doing, studies program, religious services. He was supposed to have been moved to a medium security (it was approved in Sept.), but his case manager hadn't moved it along.
In Nov., he was told his cell should be a "Black cell," and somehow they got rid his Native American cellmate. My son said, "No way." Suddenly, a knife is found in the sink drain.
I KNOW my son had nothing to do with it. I've been told by someone else that neither the guards nor people he knows believe he did this. But until his hearing, he was kept in segreation.
He wrote, "Saw the DHO today and my staff rep did not show up nor did the witness statements he was supposed to get. So she found me guilty due to culpability, gave me 4 points (no medium), 1 yeaer loss of store, 6 months loss of e-mail, 60 days hole time, 60 days on the shelf (no work), 41 days' loss of good time, and a $35 fine."
She (the judge) put down that in her opinion "the knife was not his." Yet she still punished him for something he DID NOT DO. He has too much riding to ever think of such a thing.
He is going to appeal, and I don't know what "culpability" means in this case.
To make a long story short, he asked me and his dad to "raise a stink"...and I would, but we wonder if that would be in our son's best interest. I don't want to do anything that would be harmful.
My son is in for "aggravated assault" in Indian Country. He beat up a man who was beating his pregnant wife. The jury "found" him to be Indian, although he doesn't not have enough to get any type of Indian services.
He's had his problems, but I believe this is way out of bounds. But what I want to know is, should we intervene with a letter, or stay out of it?

Samuel-II :


Samuel-II :

I am sorry to hear of this situation. I cannot tell you not to get involved. But I suggest that you are correct, you could make things more difficult for your son, as unfortunate as it is.

Samuel-II :

I mean, you could go through a lot of expense and time in trying to appeal this and by then his shelve life will be over, and only real thing he would gain is his 41 days of good time - Never gonna get back his 60 days in the hole. It seems to me that if you try to go the appeal route, it could cause him grief inside. Not supposed, to but it could.

Samuel-II :

It's up to you - but that is my take on it.

Please note that if you need more information, you can use the Reply to Expert to Continue the Conversation.

Otherwise, I would appreciate positive ratings so that I get credit for my time and information. This will NOT close your question. It will remain active for future follow ups.

If you cannot see where to Rate this service, please let me know so I can report it to the administrators of the site.

Thank you


Thank you for your input. I have absolutely no respect for the federal system. If the judge didn't think he did it, then why did she give him all this "punishment"? I am just heartsick, and I definitely want to be alive when he is released, but I can tell what it is doing to me. They never think about that. Some are ok, but on the whole I think many of them are petty demi-gods and bullies. I have absolutely no faith in the system.

Samuel II and 4 other Criminal Law Specialists are ready to help you