Ask a Business Lawyer. Get Business Law Questions Answered ASAP.
To return all the trees is a revocation of the contract and will not be permitted unless the basic goal of the contract can be said to be frustrated. Even if John accepted the trees, if he did so without knowing of the non conforming conditions, he is not precluded from recovering his damages. I do not know if there are any damages for trees that are 4 1/2 years old rather than 5 years old. HOwever, the diseased trees would be the basis for damages. Again whether he could return them will depend on the nature of the disease. If it cost $5 to cure the trees of the disease, the damage would be $5 per tree and that would be too small to rescind the contract.
Thank you. If you think this was especially helpful you can authorize a bonus. In any event I would appreciate it if you would provide feedback on the answers I provided.
If the follow up response is satisfactory please accept it and provide feed back.