Sure, kind of. There are a few economical ways.
First you may be able to find a good used panel on e-bay.com under boat and motor accessories.
Some dealers specialize in new old stock panels. While you may not find the exact panel you may find one to fit. For example try; http://greatlakesskipper.com/boat-parts/boat-consoles-panels/gauge-and-dash-panels or http://www.ebay.com/itm/like/251464337540?lpid=82&chn=ps&ul_noapp=true
Next there are some manufacturers of generic panels custom to your boat;http://www.tecnografic.com/customya.htm or http://www.custominstrumentpanels.com/boat.htm or http://www.fpmarine.com/category-s/2976.htm
Some of the gauge manufacturers make complete gauge kits with all the gauges in various styles. http://faria-instruments.com/index-marine.php You aren't limited to what you already have so shop around here.
If you are handy and have woodworking tools you can make your own panel out of aluminum or ABS plastic sheets. Lexan is also used.
Finding the exact new old stock panel may be difficult so any of these options should give you what you want. Keep in mind most of the gauges used were actually generic gauges used by many manufacturers, or can be replaced by generic gauges.
Hope this helps and if you have any further questions let me know.