Hello and welcome. If you have any questions following my answer, please let me know and I will be happy to assist further.
Is your deposit protected?
Yes, our deposit is protected with DPS
Thanks. You can go through the arbitration service of the DPS, but of course this is going to take some time. It also means that the deposit won't be released to the landlord/letting agent unless you say that is ok. The landlord/letting agent has to prove that the stain was made by you and if they can not then this will not go any further. I suggest that you contact DPS and ask for your deposit to be released. The landlord will have to agree, but this will also then go to arbitration and slightly forces the issue with the DPS. The landlord has the burden to prove that the stain was made by you and that in fact there is a stain there (if you have not seen it).. It does not help that the check out has already been done and no stain was noticed then. The amount deducted will require the landlord to prove that the carpet was new and also explain the staining. I would also be asking why cleaning first and then replacement.
Thank you. Actually the stain was noticed after the cleaning company came and before the inventory took place.
Also, I thought that the carpet to be replaced was the area of the stain, not the whole room / area. In this case, the stain is quite small, but the hallway is very big, this is why I think the replacement cost is being over evaluated.
I know from previous experience that parts of a carpet can not be replaced. It has to be the whole room. When you say after the cleaning company came, did they notice it when they cleaned?
However, to get your money back, I think that it is important to resolve this issue quickly and tell the letting agent that you will ask the DPS resolution service to address the issue as you are not prepared to release any money. Do they have any photos of the stain and before?
Whem we arrived (after 2.5 hours cleaning), the cleaning comapny said they had not noticed the stain before - although it was on the hallway on a visible place.
Is there a discount done to the quote if the carpet is not new?
They have the picture of the stain after, but not before as there was nothing
Usually it would be old for new. Obviously normal wear and tear is taken into account, but this is all down to negotation.
I think that they have a problem that there is no picture before you moved in so they can not prove it wasn't there.
What do you mean by normal wear and tear. If the carpet is more than 5 years old, it may be good for replacement, therefore we should not be paying for it to be replaced.
With regards XXXXX XXXXX before, there was noting noticed during the check in inventory. If the had been a stain, the inventory clerk would have noted it on the check in inventory report.
The landlord has to take into account normal wear and tear. Basically every day use. If however the landlord is using this as an excuse to replace the carpet because it is worn (and they happen to have found a stain) this is also not acceptable. I really believe that the best way to go is through the dispute resolutation service at the DPS. In most cases they will find in favour of the tenant. In particular where there is a doubt. I agree with whay you say about the inventory. However photos are invaluable for inventory purposes.
How do you suggest we contact DPS with regards XXXXX XXXXX resolution?
Also, when we left the flat after the check out, the stain was wet and we could not say whether it was a stain or a wet mark.
The issue we have is now we have left the UK, we said the cleaning company would come back to make additional cleaning if necessary - which the agency refused to do - and we are unable to veryfy in person whether the stain was still there or not.
You can call then on 0844 4727 000 with your ID number and they will discuss with you.
I see what you say about being overseas now. Do you know someone who could inspect for you?
This is a problem.
There are professional who can check these for you, but obviously there is a fee.
I think the agency / the landlord are using the fact we are away.
I think that you best bet is to either call +44 (0)(NNN) NNN-NNNN (as you are overseas) and discuss the issue with the DPS. This is the webpage to look at. http://www.depositprotection.com/help/tenants.aspx Hopefully you can resolve this through the DPS Alternative Dispute Resolutation Service.
Can the agency / landlord refuse? Or what happens if the landlord already changed the carpet?
I mean refuse to have the flat checked.
They can refuse to have it checked, but if they agree to arbitration then they need to produce evidence. Even if the carpet is changed already it does not mean that they can just take your money. They can only do so if you agree.
Also, the agency refused to have the cleaning company to go back to clean the flat, I doubt they will agree to have a third party to come back.
I don't think that will help much anyway. If they agree to arbitration it will be resolved.
Is there a best was to approach DPS for the arbitration? Will we have to produce a report? Evidence?
As I mentioned, give them a call and discuss what to do next. Tell them you have a dispute and ask how it can be refered to their Dispute Resolutation Service. You won't have to provide a report, just tell them the facts. The landlord should provide evidence as they seek the release of the deposit.
We already asked for the dispute resolution
This may help you. http://www.depositprotection.com/help/browse/insured/tenant/alternative-dispute-resolution
What was the outcome?
We ask for the release of the dispute
Sorry? Do you mean you asked for the release of the deposit? That is not the same thing. If you have a disagreement you use the dispute resolution service. They assist with problems.
The status on the DPS site is "In dispute resolution, awaiting landlord evidence"
We asked for the release of the deposit
with the expected amount
The agency received it, and the landlord put the amount they want to release
and now it is in dispute resolution
In that case, all you can do is wait. They have 14 days in which to submit evidence. You will then receive this evidence and have a chance to respond within 14 days.
When we answer, what would be the best way to say the stain was there (or not when) we moved in. Also, on the check out inventory report there is only a picture of the wet stain (this is mentionned by the clerk) and it is difficult to say whether the stain will remain or not and it is not difficult / impossible to check in person.
Could you please provide some wording as what we should tell write the DPS dispute resolution service?
It is important to say that the stain was not there when you moved out. There is no evidence that it was there when you moved out.
I am afraid that i can't really provide wording. All you can really say is that you believe that the stain can be removed by cleaning and the costs of replacing the carpet are disportionate to the stain and the age of the carpet.
I'm sorry but I have to sign off now. Is there anything else for the moment?
The evidence might be the check out inventory
Ok, thank you
DISCLAIMER: Answers from Experts on JustAnswer are not substitutes for the advice of an attorney. JustAnswer is a public forum and questions and responses are not private or confidential or protected by the attorney-client privilege. The Expert above is not your attorney, and the response above is not legal advice. You should not read this response to propose specific action or address specific circumstances, but only to give you a sense of general principles of law that might affect the situation you describe. Application of these general principles to particular circumstances must be done by a lawyer who has spoken with you in confidence, learned all relevant information, and explored various options. Before acting on these general principles, you should hire a lawyer licensed to practice law in the jurisdiction to which your question pertains.
The responses above are from individual Experts, not JustAnswer. The site and services are provided “as is”. To view the verified credential of an Expert, click on the “Verified” symbol in the Expert’s profile. This site is not for emergency questions which should be directed immediately by telephone or in-person to qualified professionals. Please carefully read the Terms of Service (last updated February 8, 2012).