How JustAnswer Works:
  • Ask an Expert
    Experts are full of valuable knowledge and are ready to help with any question. Credentials confirmed by a Fortune 500 verification firm.
  • Get a Professional Answer
    Via email, text message, or notification as you wait on our site.
    Ask follow up questions if you need to.
  • 100% Satisfaction Guarantee
    Rate the answer you receive.
Ask USTaxAdvising Your Own Question
USTaxAdvising, CPA
Category: Tax
Satisfied Customers: 1236
Experience:  US Taxation specialist.
Type Your Tax Question Here...
USTaxAdvising is online now
A new question is answered every 9 seconds

Do I want to make an irrevocable election on this tax return

This answer was rated:

Do I want to make an irrevocable election on this tax return under Article XVIII(7) of US-Canada income tax treaty to defer the income accrued on a RRIF for 2011 and all future years? What are the ramifications of my answering yes or no???



Very good question. Most of the time I see U.S. Citizens with RRSPs or RRIFs making this election. The reason being is that the timing of taxation by Canada and the U.S. is the same (this helps with foreign tax credit planning purposes).


Being a U.S. citizen you are taxed on your worldwide income. This includes the income generated by the RRIF/RRSP. By making this election you are electing to tax the income the RRIF/RRSP has made when you take a cash distribution from the account, not as it is earned in the account.


Generally it is preferably to make this election for foreign tax credit planning purposes. When you take a cash distribution Canada will tax you on it, and assuming you have made the election, the U.S. will tax you on it as well. Given the foreign tax credit the U.S. tax basically gets canceled out. Absent the election the U.S. will tax you on the annual income the RRSP/RRIF earns but you won't have any Canadian taxes paid to get a foreign tax credit. Absent the election you'll pay tax in the U.S. on it as it is earned and in Canada as you take cash distributions. (generally not preferable)


Don't forget to file an FBAR and the 8938 to report the account and asset.


Please let me know if you have any further questions.


Best regards

USTaxAdvising and 5 other Tax Specialists are ready to help you
Customer: replied 4 years ago.
My husband has been a resident of the US since 1996 - thus has not made any contributions since then. We have never claimed the RRIF (RRSP until last year, when he turned age 72) on US tax forms. He had to take a distribution in 2011, for which he had taxes held by Canada for being a non-resident. 1.) Do we still want to answer affirmatively to the Article XVIII(7) deferral? 2.) Will we get the Canadian taxes back? 3.)Are we now subject to the "double taxation"??

Thank you

Ok so your husband became a U.S. resident/citizen in 1996 and has not made contributions to the RRIF since 1996. Being that he is a U.S. citizen/resident he should have been disclosing the RRIF on Form 8891 (see below) annually and including the income from the RRIF on his Form 1040.(absent the election)


1.) Do we still want to answer affirmatively to the Article XVIII(7) deferral? - the choice is yours. If you do not elect deferral then any income the fund earns during the year must be reported and it will be taxed as if it were distributed. (see my comments on the prior post, generally most U.S. citizens whom own such assets make this election)


2.) Will we get the Canadian taxes back? - You probably won't get the Canadian taxes back. The RRIF was contributed to with "PRE-Tax" dollars so Canada will tax it on distribution. You might be able to file a Canadian return to get a refund of the taxes paid.


3.)Are we now subject to the "double taxation"?? - not really but somewhat (absent the election). If you don't elect you won't get the benefit of the foreign tax credit until Canada taxes the distribution. The U.S. will tax the earnings even though it is not distributed. With the election you get to report the "distribution" as income to both countries in the same year and maximize the foreign tax credit.


I hope this helps, please let me know if you have any further questions. If you choose to make the election (which is strongly preferable) be sure to mark part 6c of the 8891 so that the election is irrevocable for the current year and all subsequent years.


Form 8891 -

Related Tax Questions