South Africa Law
Ask a South Africa Law Question, Get an Answer ASAP!
I am a UK citizen and have a house in S Africa. It is rented out as a holiday home for 10 months of the year and managed for me by a friend. We have no written agreement but this has been the situation since 2008. It is co-owned with my wife, also a UK citizen. I have a will in the UK but this property is not specifically covered in that will. I realise I should probably correct that but my question is what happens here if my wife and I were wiped out in a road accident, for example. I want to ensure that the property is able to continue normally as a holiday rental and it would be my intention to leave the property (which has a 50% bond) to my friend here. Are there any special considerations?
Thanks for your question. Please RATE my answer when you are satisfied
Does your wife also have a UK will please?
Would you like to continue?
Sorry, have been out all day. But I notice you are from UK Law whereas the advice I need relates to SA Law. We both have UK wills but I know we shall have to amend them when we get back because we have not specified any wishes regarding the S Africa property. My immediate concern would be that my friend who runs the property here in S Africa would suddenly find he had no access to the property and that the business arrangement that has existed her for the last 5 years would not suddenly stop. I had thought I would write a separate will relating only to my S African property (a copy of which would be attached to my UK will) want to be sure that
contd ... (a copy of which would be attached to my UK will) but the S Africa will would be deposited with my Bank or other agent here, with the knowledge of my friend here, so that in the event of our joint deaths, there would be no confusion about the S A property. My wife's SA will contain the same terms and I understand the assumption that the older person is deemed to die first and the younger partners will then becomes the over-riding document. We also do not want to tell our friend that he will inherit the property.
No worries. Thanks. Just reading your posts...
Your UK wills, unless you specifically specify otherwise will effect your worldwide property including south African property. If you both died together the younger of you will be deemed to have died second.
If you wish to ensure that the property is left to a specific individual then you need to provide for the same in your UK will. This will take effect in South Africa although it is in your UK will.
Having said that many people who have foreign property choose to make a seperate will in the country in which that property is located. You can do this but should you do so take care to provide in your UK will that your UK will does not effect your SA property otherwise any subsequent UK will you make can override any will you make in SA previously and vice versa. Similarly your SA will if you choose to make one should declare that it only relates to you SA property or the same could possibly apply in reverse.
In terms of whether there are any legal implications in how to leave the property in SA as you say you would need advice from a SA lawyer as I am as an English lawyer. This site does have a SA section I think and you could consider posting a question in the SA section where one of my colleagues may be able to assist you.
My concern has arisen because a friend here in a similar situation has advised me there can be problems relating to S African assets regardless of what might be specified in any UK wills. His concern related to liquidation of S African assets the repatriation of any funds to the UK, which is not directly a concern in my case, but I just need to be aware of all the potential snags to be sure I have thought them through. So it is a S African legal problem, not necessarily a UK problem, and I do have a solicitor in the UK who will advise me from a UK perspective.
I always advise my clients who own foreign property to take advice from a local lawyer in that country and consider whether to make a local will in addition to a UK will which wills cross refer to each other as above so as not to accidentally cancel each other out.
Sorry we crossed, but my application was made to the SA section because the advice I wanted was specifically related to SA Law, so I was surprised that your reply came from the UK.
The reason for this is that some countries have succession laws which override ones will - one only has to look as far as France to find such a situation where it is very difficult not to leave your estate to your spouse and children regardless of what it says in your will.
I also understand the traps that can occur with a secondary will taking over from the first and will take care of that back in the UK. So it is the SA specifics I need an answer to.
Thanks for your help but can I get back to the S African site?
Looking at the information available on PLC SA laws allow full testamentary freedom which, in essence, permits a testator to freely dispose of the entirety of his estate, subject only to the law and public policy. There is no forced heirship regime. It also recognises UK wills
I suggest you post a question in the SA legal section where a SA lawyer will no doubt be able to give specific assistance on SA law. If you have any difficutly posting a question in that section, customer services will be pleased to help. Sorry if you did not mean ti post in the UK section.
HI Joshua, I have been asked to rate your service and as far as your response is concerned, it was excellent. However, I have not learnt anything I did not already know since it is only the SA aspects that I need information on and my original enquiry was directed to the SA site. So, I am not a satisfied customer althought that has nothing to do with you. Thanks for trying anyway! Rgds etc
Hi Joshua, that sounds like an excellent suggestion and I am confident there will be someone there to help because I did research a few replies before completing my application. As I recall events,having made my payment (Paypal UK a/c) I was ended up on the UK site and I did not see any obvious way to extricate myself and get back to the S African site. You might like to feed that back somehow. The fault might have been mine but I am quite computer savvy and would be surprised if it had been. Rgds etc.
Hi SA-TOPLAW, Many thanks to everyone for picking up on my need for SA info! Your answer makes things fairly clear and I shall do what I can whilst I am here to do what has to be done at the SA end.
Just one question, and you might not be the right person to answer, but my estate will be liable to UK estate duty on its combined worldwide value, of which the first £300k or so is exempt. There may also be an exempt portion in SA, do you know how much that normally is?
Would it then be that SA Revenue will take what they require subject to any exemptions, and as far as UK Revenue is concerned, my UK estate duty debt is then credited with whatever payment has already been made in SA. Kind of a Witholding Tax arrangement?
Hi SA-TOPLAW, many thanks for the reply, that is all now fairly clear and I shall take steps to get things organised here before I return to the UK. Just one small thought, this whole thing arose because I was concerned about the situation where my wife and I were both wiped out in a joint accident. In UK law, the younger partner is deemed to have outlived the older, therefore that will is over-riding. I presume the same applies here?
Other than that, I am perfectly happy with the responses I have received so many thanks to both of you. Regards etc
Many thanks for your prompt reply, no further questions! Rgds etc
DISCLAIMER: Answers from Experts on JustAnswer are not substitutes for the advice of an attorney. JustAnswer is a public forum and questions and responses are not private or confidential or protected by the attorney-client privilege. The Expert above is not your attorney, and the response above is not legal advice. You should not read this response to propose specific action or address specific circumstances, but only to give you a sense of general principles of law that might affect the situation you describe. Application of these general principles to particular circumstances must be done by a lawyer who has spoken with you in confidence, learned all relevant information, and explored various options. Before acting on these general principles, you should hire a lawyer licensed to practice law in the jurisdiction to which your question pertains.
The responses above are from individual Experts, not JustAnswer. The site and services are provided “as is”. To view the verified credential of an Expert, click on the “Verified” symbol in the Expert’s profile. This site is not for emergency questions which should be directed immediately by telephone or in-person to qualified professionals. Please carefully read the Terms of Service (last updated February 8, 2012).