It sounds like you are genuinely confused. Start by identifying what you want in a girlfriend. If sex is at the top then put it at the top. This is just for you and you should be brutally. See which girl meets most of your requirements. Also consider the negative aspects of each girl. Try to look past superficial qualities such as looks. But if the one girl's looks bother you then you should not waste any more of her time. You have to be honest with yourself as well. Everything is a compromise but if her looks or her sexual performance is important then you should consider that. If something is a deal breaker like these things you may rule in her favor. When something is a deal breaker there is no point in going any further.
Whatever your decision is you have to be honest with yourself and them. You have to go with your judgment and trust that you are making the right decision. There is no way to know that your decision is right in the long run. Life offers no guarantees. Think about what I have said and apply the details. Start with what is important.
Please press accept; this is the only way I am compensated