Real Estate Law
Have Real Estate Law Questions? Ask a Real Estate Lawyer.
Thanks for getting back with me on this question. I can't give you a definitive opinion as to whether or not you absolutely can require them to do as you wish with regard to the new drain. He may have a prescriptive right to claim the current route via the long time usage of it. Situations like this are usually worked out by the neighbors by agreement, rather than through expensive court battles. I know that sounds like I'm begging off, but without going into extensive research and finding appropriate cases on the subject, which may be few and far between, that's probably the way your local court would handle it. Who knows? Perhaps your neighbor would be perfectly willing to work it out voluntarily. That is your logical starting point.
I wish to add that in Indiana the county surveyor is in charge of all legal ditches, if that is what you have. S/he is the person who is in the best position to advise you as to your rights, in the case of a legal ditch or drain that crosses your property. My apologies for not being more definite, but without spending hours on obtaining more facts and doing case research, this is as definite as I can be.