Real Estate Law
Have Real Estate Law Questions? Ask a Real Estate Lawyer.
Hello and thank you for your question. Is there in anything in Bylaws that states why this fee is charged or what it actually covers?
I have a copy of the ByLaws from the HOA - hold a few minutes please
No - the ByLaws were signed in the year 2000 and probably have not been reviewed by the HOA board.
Are you familiar with Colorado Law and the standard Buy/Sell contract? In the "offer" I made it states that certain documents "will be provided by the Seller - I have agreed with the seller to pay half of her expenses - I'm looking into this for both of us. She has authorized the release of these documents and has already provided me with most of the documents
Yes I am familiar with the laws and the contract. The association cannot create costs that are not stated in the Bylaws or approved by the board and added as amendments to the bylaws. The Attorney General for Colorado is tasked with consumer protection for the state. They will take complaints and open an investigation with regard to Homeowners Associations
File a consumer complaint calling 1-800-222-4444 or sending an e-mail to [email protected].
Associations can charge for these closing packets and most of them do charge. That being said the authorization to charge must be contain in the declaration and bylaws.
Our realtor (working for both because it was a "for sale by owner") had anticipated a possible fee of $15 to $30 by the management company.
I believe that you have already earned your $72! Do you have any more to say on this?
Have I worded the complaint to you well enough to use?
I don't make $72.00 on your question. The site handles the charges and we do not know how much yo pay them. That being said I understand your frustration with the association. If they have nothing to back up the charge I would file the complaint.
You worded your question perfectly.
Thank You ... I believe that you have really helped me and, actually, my HOA. Much appreciated!!
Are We done or do you have anything further to say?
My pleasure. Will you let me know what happens? You can return to your question at anytime to ask me any follow up questions that you may have for me.
OK, I'll do that ... thanks!
Thank you. If you would be kind enough to rate my service I would be most appreciative.
Will do - Excellent and I will click on that emoticon upon exit ...
I have further problems with this. It it going to cost me more to ask further questions?
In discussing this with my realtor, he told me that all the Title company was requesting of the Mgt Company was a letter about possible dues arrears. Today, he said this:
"I spoke with Land Title just now for your inquiry. They had requested to receive the information from Faith Property Management by tomorrow, so they do not have anything yet."I called Faith again as well and did find out that the Transfer Fee is a property management fee billed to each sale transaction, regardless of which HOA the property is a part of. It is a not a fee created by or voted on by the HOA board or homeowners. By contracting with Faith, the HOAs who do so are subject to their fees."
Note that the HOA pays the mgt company about $400 a month for their services. Here's what I sent back to my realtor: The current homeowner is "Jan" and the mgt company is "Faith Mgt Co."
"I am not happy with the Faith answer. In my opinion, Faith is NOT managing Jan's property. They are responsible only for common areas in the HOA. Simply because they are under contract to the HOA does not give them the right to take money out of the closing of the private property owned by the homeowners. The request for dues information (which, as I understand it) is an HOA responsibility and, under Colorado law, any charges for that service must be in the bylaws, so I am told. I still see what Faith is doing is taking advantage of a situation which has never been questioned before. They are gouging people simply because nobody has stopped them. I'll get to the bottom of this yet! Further, Faith is being paid for their management services so why are they extracting further fees."
Wish I knew your first name, Attorney2 just doesn't hack it! I'm goung to call you Butch. Butch, the fee is $300 and still outrageous. I realize that it is the HOA's responsibility but the HOA is not charging that fee, the mgt company is and separate from their HOA duties as I understand them. Are they or are they not acting on behalf of the HOA by providing a "dues" letter, not acting independently? That's the legal question. What gives them the right to create charges at the closing? Their statement, "the Transfer Fee is a property management fee billed to each sale transaction, regardless of which HOA the property is a part of." What gives them the right to charge a fee independently of the HOA? Am I correct in saying that the mgt company is only responsible for "common" property" management? They are not managing the personal homeowner owned condo properties, are they?
Butch, you have stated before that you would like me to keep you informed about what happens and again, above, that you will be curious to know how they justify their charges. Do I give you that information by coming back online through these question/answer chats?
Please excuse the delay. I have been reading through a) the ByLaws, b) the Rules and Regs and c) the covenants (61 pages) also referred to as the Declaration(s). None of these documents have been amended or modified in any way since the year 2000.
"What would be the female equivalent of butch?" ... you really do not want to know! (joke Joke
Attachments are only available to registered users.
Suzy-Q, There is no place in the documents mentioned above where a any fee (board or management company generated) is identified for the process of providing a "closing" or "dues" letter. Fees are mentioned in in the covenants stating that the HOA can charge a fee for, 1) homeowner use of Common Elements, 2) late assessment (dues) payments and 3) "... a reasonable charge for the preparation and recordation of supplements or amendments to the covenants." Also in the covenants is a section which provides the board the right to contract for property management. I do not know what the actual contract says with respect to the management company. Finally, the standard Colorado Contract to Buy and Sell Real Estate (Residential) has a section identifying "Association" fees to be paid at closing but there is nothing saying that the association management company can charge independent fees. It mentions Status Letter and Record Change Feesand even Private Trans Fees but they are all called Association Fees. This association does not appear to be aware of how to operate and appears to be "managed" by the property management company. When I mentioned this fee to the president of the association, he emailed the property manager and cc:'d me saying to the property manager, "Jim Bernier (cc'd on this email) is asking about the $300 transfer fee imposed by the HOA. I have never been involved in this process as the previous account manager always handled this. Can you explain what this is for?" ... I'd say that this association and board is a bit lax in management.
I believe that nothing I have done so far will keep the management company from making the $300 charge at closing. I'm going to write a letter of protest to be delivered at the closing for the record and possibly have the seller, Jan, also sign it. Can you think of any specific wording I should use? I will also be taking your advice about addressing this to the Attorney General/consumer protection people.
Thanks, Suzy-Q ... be well. I will look for a further reply from you in the morning, no need to work on it any more tonight. I will be signing off after sending this. - JEB
DISCLAIMER: Answers from Experts on JustAnswer are not substitutes for the advice of an attorney. JustAnswer is a public forum and questions and responses are not private or confidential or protected by the attorney-client privilege. The Expert above is not your attorney, and the response above is not legal advice. You should not read this response to propose specific action or address specific circumstances, but only to give you a sense of general principles of law that might affect the situation you describe. Application of these general principles to particular circumstances must be done by a lawyer who has spoken with you in confidence, learned all relevant information, and explored various options. Before acting on these general principles, you should hire a lawyer licensed to practice law in the jurisdiction to which your question pertains.
The responses above are from individual Experts, not JustAnswer. The site and services are provided “as is”. To view the verified credential of an Expert, click on the “Verified” symbol in the Expert’s profile. This site is not for emergency questions which should be directed immediately by telephone or in-person to qualified professionals. Please carefully read the Terms of Service (last updated February 8, 2012).