Real Estate Law
Have Real Estate Law Questions? Ask a Real Estate Lawyer.
If the HOA bylaws do not specify a roof color, I think you've got a legitimate defense to their demands. My suggestion is to have an attorney review the bylaws and advise whether your position is valid based on the bylaws.
If so, you should file a lawsuit against the HOA to stop them from fining you or forcing you to replace the roof.
What type of attorney should I contact? I'm in Georgia