JustAnswer > Mental Health
Ask A Question|Register|Login|Help
JustAnswer

Mental Health

Ask a Mental Health Question, Get an Answer ASAP!

Have your own Mental Health question?

2 Psychiatrists and Psychologists are Online Now
characters left:
Not a Mental Health Question?

Related Mental Health Topics:

  • Age
  • ,
  • May
  • ,
  • Men
  • ,
  • Man
  • ,
  • Six
  • ,
  • Son
  • ,
  • Sun
  • ,
  • Two
  • ,
  • Back
  • ,
  • Come
Bookmark and Share

Question

Its taken me a long time to come to terms with writing this story ... anyway here goes: My relationship of 17 + months seems so perfect ... apart from some nagging issues, which appear to be only coming from me!? I am the one who initiates discussions around our future together, such as marriage, other financial plans, and projects ... This be as a result of my boyfriend "living for today" (as he lost his childhood sweetheart and soul mate to a terminal illness six years ago; I can only imagine what he went through)? I often wonder about why a man of his age has given away all of his finances to the children, and has left himself with nothing (not even a home to live in) ... Could this be because he is such a selfless person (he is very supportive and family orientated)? Perhaps his soul mate's wishes were for him to "look after the children". Perhaps he felt that he would never re-marry and that because he helped his children to buy their own homes, he would always have a place to stay!? My boyfriend also has a commitment to his son, to help look after his grandchild. I actually like this aspect about him. However, this commitment could go on for another year or more, while he is needed to "fetch and carry" from play school. Perhaps this makes him hesitant to initiate the kind of discussions that I always seem to initiate, because he is focussing on "today". I know that it is in my nature to plan for the future. The fact that he has no money, could be another reason for him not wanting to initiate discussions around our future or finances? I have asked him this, and he has agreed that this is the case, and that he "regrets having made stupid decisions" before finding me. Once I have opened the discussion, my boyfriend does enter into the spirit of things, to a degree .... I keep feeling that we would not discuss any plans or our future, if it was not for me. He also says that he cannot get involved in my financial plans, because it is not his place to do so, as he cannot contribute financially. Sometimes I think that, as we have such a beautiful relationship (he phones me everyday, is so loving and supportive, communicates well, does not seem to hide things or have a hidden agenda, and is very helpful and handy), that I could be over reacting from past hurts, and therefore am now looking for issues!? In my previous marriage (of 30 years duration), my then husband turned the tables on me, and eventually started treating me as though he had become successful all on his own; that I was a "non contributor". The last thing that I would want to happen, is to treat anyone the way I was treated (especially finances). So the past comes up and clearly is part of my conditioning ... The other thing that I am battling with, is tolerance or underlying anger and sarcasm. On more than a few occasions, my boyfriend (now fiancé ... still feel that, had I not broached the subject in a round about manner, I may not be wearing his ring!?), has snapped at me or said something sarcastic, usually whilst we were working on a project together. This hurts, as I am a very tolerant person. I did let him know how I felt (as I do not want to do what I did in the past, by going into my shell and storing things up). As a result, he is more mindful now, or maybe controlled!? A few past relationships have shown me that certain men (that I had to move away from), were intolerant, angry and pretty scary people. My fiancé is a good man, and seems to have excellent values. He says that I have encouraged him to be open and honest, and that he opens up more with me than he ever did. Another thing, early in our relationship, we went to one of my girlfriends for dinner ... when he saw her (with some of her friends on the sidewalk), he went off the road and climbed the sidewalk with the car (don't laugh!). I thought about this and wondered what was going through his head ... he is such a careful driver!? Was there something to worry about? The other night my fiancé went to a presentation (no partner invited!?), and when he came back (early, around 9 pm), he smelled so heavily of deodorant or perfume. When I asked him what he was wearing because it smelled rather strong, he said that he had bought a new deodorant; the smell lasted all night! He never questions me about my past and I try not to delve into his. My fiancé now spends four days at my home and three days at his son home. He seems to want to be with me all the time, except for his commitment days. He is very focussed when we are together, and things are really very good, apart from these niggling things that I am sharing. When I stayed over at his son's one night, I noticed that my fiancé keeps Olay sunscreen in the bathroom cupboard (is this for men too!?), as well as his deceased wife's hair brush in the drawer, and now he has some pink Swarkzskof shampoo and conditioner in the bathroom along side his anti-dandruff shampoo and conditioner ... what am I thinking??? He keeps photos of his deceased wife, along with their wedding photos, on his bedroom dressing table. On a few occasions his grandson has come into the room, picked up the album from the dresser, and pointed out all the pictures of only his "nana" (as if pointing to a particular cartoon character in a picture book). I could understand my fiancé pointing out "his nana", to his grandson, However, his grandson was not born when "nana" died, so I think that my fiancé is still carrying deep grief for her parting. When I mentioned that he must still be grieving from his wife's parting, he put our photograph in the front of this album. He also said that his son must have told his grandson about his nana. So he is very sensitive and seems to want to do the right thing ... (the wedding photos are still in the album though ... hmmmmmm). Maybe this is "nothing"!? My fiancé always seems to have a plausible answer to my queries, which makes me feel that I am being sceptical, sensitive and perhaps over-reacting ... these feelings do not go away. The past could have a lot to do with how I view life today ... In my past I have been lied to, deceived, and cheated on. I want better for my life this time around, yet I want to be reasonable and objective. I find myself wanting to keep things good, yet feel that maybe I am overlooking some important issues!? I do not share this with my girlfriends; most of them have greater problems of their own. Rather I am sharing this with you, in the hopes that I can come to terms with my feelings and fears. A part of me feels that there should be "nothing to worry about". These feelings that come up every now and again in our relationship, are mildly similar to those that came up during my 30 year marriage ... and I have since found out that those very feelings and concerns that I used to have in the past, were very accurate (people, and family members have confirmed many!) We do have such a good relationship, yet a part of me feels that I am looking for flaws, secretly wanting to sabotage this relationship, and another part of me feels that because I am so in love, I am not seeing things clearly!? And I feel like a traitor to be writing this, yet feel the need to do this ... Kind regards

Submitted: 132 days and 1 hours ago.
Category: Mental Health
Value: $15
Status: CLOSED
+
Read More

Optional Information

Gender: Female
Age: 54

Already Tried:
Communicating with my fiance and being as diplomatic and honest as I can.

Accepted Answer

Hi and welcome Your fiance sounds like a man who lost his wife, and did not feel the need for anything , so he gave everything to his children. He sought refuge in his family, pretty nice actually. That was his choice and then along you come and life changes for him yet again. He sounds like he tries to "do the right thing" for all of you. Yes, a lot of your concerns come from your past experiences and your fears and suspicions are the result. You are not 100% trusting of him based on your marriage experience. He does not sound like the type of man who has the time , money or personality to deceive you. He is devoted to his family and you (ring on your finger, yes?). I agree that you may be looking for problems and there is a hyper-vigilance about you due to your marriage woes and deceptions. I would suggest that you see a psychologist if you keep feeling this way, you need to find someone to help you clear away the remnants of doubt you have leftover from your marriage, Then you can go into this marriage (whenever that may be) fully trusting. It sounds like you are both committed to this relationship. You are able to get him to talk and once you do he's open to discussions. As far as the shampoo and sun screen, why not? It may just have ben on sale and it may not be important to him as to brand, it was shampoo and sun screen . Don't torture yourself analyzing every behavior or decision. The past is over, he will always be in love with the memory of his deceased wife and that's okay. You love him, he loves you and every family has arguments so let that go. He is doing his best to deal with his loss and you are doing to best to get over a bad marriage. I would suggest you enjoy these times with him and understand that you are not trying to sabbotage the relationship, you are comparing this man with men who were not honest or nice to you. He isn't any of these men and you need to relax about all of it and enjoy each other. It will all fall into place in due time. Please click ACCEPT and leave FEEDBACK when you are satisfied.

Picture
Expert: Dr.Keane
Pos. Feedback: 99.3 %
Accepts: 441
Answered: 11/4/2009

Psychologist

Clinical Psychology PHD, Licensed Professional Counselor, Marriage/Family, Teens, Child Psychology,

131 days and 5 hours ago.

Reply

Dr Keane,

Thank you so much for your wonderful feedback ... your answer is what my logical side tell my "illogical" (sceptical, fear based) side ... you have left me with such a warm, loving feeling, for this very special man ... and tears in my eyes

You are truly a wonderful person too, with such a warm heart ... thank you again!

131 days and 4 hours ago.

Reply

Hello Dr Keane,

I messed up whilst trying to do the Paypal payment and was not sure whether to re-enter the deposit or not, as I had already put that amount into Paypal before.

Anyway, next time I will get it right.

Thank you again

127 days and 2 hours ago.

Reply

Dear Dr Keane,

Thank you for taking the time and care to reply to my feedback ... again, such warmth and caring. Its truly wonderful to have people like yourself, to share with and to receive the kind of feedback that leaves me feeling warm, and contented. May you continue to touch people the way you do, and be touched back two fold.

Kind regards, XXXXXX (Linda)

 

+
Read More

Related Mental Health Questions

  • i've recently had a baby (18wks ago). i keep putting myself
  • I have a mantel helth prblam, I forget more and cant get con...
  • i think i may have borderline personality disorder.
  • I've a daughter that is 8 1/2 years old. She's vastly under
  • I was fired in June and I have been avoiding looking for a
  • Please could you advise me of how to get tested for dyscalcu...
  • 44 yr old woman, functioning well until 4 yrs ago, 13 inpati...
  • My husband had an emotional affair with a co worker, And ma...



Disclaimer: Information in questions, answers, and other posts on this site ("Posts") comes from individual users, not JustAnswer; JustAnswer is not responsible for Posts. Posts are for general information, are not intended to substitute for informed professional advice (medical, legal, veterinary, financial, etc.), or to establish a professional-client relationship. The site and services are provided "as is" with no warranty or representations by JustAnswer regarding the qualifications of Experts. To see what credentials have been verified by a third-party service, please click on the "Verified" symbol in some Experts' profiles. JustAnswer is not intended or designed for EMERGENCY questions which should be directed immediately by telephone or in-person to qualified professionals.
Question List | Become an Expert | Terms of Service | Security & Privacy | About Us
© 2003-2010 JustAnswer Corp.