Hello and welcome to Just Answer.
How big of a gas mileage decrease are you talking about?
What year is the car?
How much oil was extracted from the old system?
How much oil was added to the new system?
What type of oil was used?
That could be your problem. R134a and R12 oils are not compatible. If 3-4 ounces of R12 oil was in the system and you added the supplied oil, there will be way too much oil in the system, and the wrong type of oil.
What other components were replaced with the retrofit kit?
The BMW literature says 3.4 ounces of oil.
Too much oil could be the issue.
I would check the pressures first before you evac the system again.
BMW Master technician
BMW S.T.E.P. graduate, 10 years BMW dealership experience