JustAnswer > Legal
Ask A Question|Register|Login|Help
JustAnswer

Law

Ask a Legal Question, Get an Answer ASAP!

Have your own Legal question?

11 Lawyers are Online Now
characters left:
Not a Legal Question?

Question

I have a couple of questions. First, the background. On May 11, 2008, my live in boyfriend (we no longer live together) got into an argument. Through the course of the argument, he pushed through a balcony doorway and as a result suffered two torn ligaments in my right knee. I immediately had him arrested. He did admit to pushing me in the police report and subsequently, pled guilty to domestic assualt.

The criminal court did not order him to pay for my medical treatment and now I'd like to sue him for the cost of the surgery and my lost wages. I live in Minnesota and since my claim is less than $7500, I'm told I have to sue him in conciliation court. I'm told the judge won't rule on the wages that I'm going to lose as a result of the knee surgery. Is this true? If so, do I have any other options? My total estimated expenses are $5,080. Do I have to incur the expenses before I sue (i.e. have the surgery first)?

Submitted: 148 days and 15 hours ago.
Category: Legal
Value: $15
Status: AWAITING CUSTOMER ACTION
+
Read More

Optional Information

Minnesota

Already Tried:
I've done nothing yet. I have gathered all of my evidence (i.e. police report, court judgement, doctor's report, MRIs, and cost estimates). I plan to file in small claims (conciliation court) within the next month.

Posted by Stephanie O. Joy, Esq. 148 days and 15 hours ago.

Info Request

Dear Anna,

 

Thank you for your question and I look forward to working on your answer. Please keep in mind that I can only respond to your post and the information contained in it, as I do not know what you know unless you describe it fully. Also, due to site tech reasons, oftentimes I am initially only able to see the first part of your post, so I apologize in advance if I ask a redundant question.

 

That being said, in order to better assist you, could you please clarify for me:

 

1. Your country and state?

 

I look forward to getting to work on this for you. Hang in there!

 

Sincerely,

 

Stephanie O. Joy, JA Legal Expert

 

Please note: A times there can be a delay of an hour or more in between my answers because I may be helping other customers or taking a break. In addition, if it is late at night, EST, and we are between postings, I may go get some shut eye, but I'll be back the next day, so never fear. On Saturday, there will be greater gaps in time due to scheduling, for any needed follow up, but rest assured, by day's end it will be done.

Posted by Stephanie O. Joy, Esq. 148 days and 14 hours ago.

Answer

Dear Anna, the remainder of your post came up and now I see you are in MN.

 

I must urge you to reconsider any decision to file in Conciliation court. Conciliation Court is also known as "small claims" court. Claims of $7,500 or less can be filed in Conciliation Court. Once you file a claim, you cannot later file another claim for more money related to the same event(s). Conciliation Court procedures are easier to follow and the filing fee is lower than the District Court level. You do not need a lawyer to go to Concilation Court. However, your damages could be far highter than $7500! (I know that employees and sue employer for wages, but I'm not seeing that a personal injury plaintiff can't sue the the liable defendant. You not only have medical expenses, lost wages, 'pain and suffering' which is the mainstay of a personal injury suit. This is the part of damages where the big bucks are involved. Not to sound mercenary here, but I'm sure you suffered pain and suffering, couldn't play hoops for a while, etc. Moreover, depending on your current medicals, you could have permanent damages, maybe some pain on rainy days, or pain when you walk to far, etc. Maybe you had to be on crutches all summer of 2008 and lost all of your normal summer enjoyment for an entire season. Maybe your big skiing hobby is really not safe to do anymore and so you can't ski anymore. These are the losses to quality of life that add value to your case.

 

OK, and let's say you are the kind of person (and I understand this) that says, no, I just want my out of pocket losses covered, I don't want to sue for that. Here is why you may also want to at least approach it from that way: If you sue in small claim, the defendant knows that worst case scenario, he is on the hook for $7500, no matter what. So, he can't hurt himself by fighting it and he has no incentive really to settle it before hand to avoid a risky verdict of a high amount. In the higher court, however, the sky is the limit (so to speak) and you could get a 6 figure award against him. He may have incentive to settle it to protect himself. You could still be generous with him if you chose. I.e. medicals and loss of wages and $10k for pain and suffering, but you could go the length too if he is not amenable to paying up somewhat for what he has caused.

 

 

Hope this helps to clarify.


 

I believe I have answered your question and I hope you a better understanding of your legal issue as a result. As you know, I am only the messenger and can not create favorable law if it doesn't exist, so please don't hold it against me if the legal result is not what you wish. If your question was in fact answered appropriately please click the GREEN "ACCEPT" button NOW, in order that it be recognized as such and I receive credit for my work from the company. Your promptness is greatly appreciated. In addition, Positive "FEEDBACK" and BONUSES are also appreciated. If you need additional related follow up on this particular question afterwards, don't hesitate to Reply and I'm happy to help you. And if you would like my assistance in the future, just put my name, STEPHANIE JOY, in your title or first sentence of post. Please keep in mind that I can only respond to your post and the information contained in it, as I do not know what you know unless you describe it fully. Also, due to site tech reasons, oftentimes I am initially only able to see the first part of your post, so I apologize in advance if it means more interactions between us. At times, there can also be a delay of an hour or more in between my answers because I may be helping other customers or taking a break, or if it is late at night, I may have to go get some shut eye til morning, but rest assured, I'll be back for you. Thanks!

Sincerely,

 

Stephanie Joy

 

 

My Standard and Required Legal Disclaimer. The information given by me here is not legal advice. You should not and may not rely on anything on this website as legal advice and you agree that the nominal price you may pay for information here clearly does not pay for any legal advice. I am neither establishing nor accepting an attorney-client relationship with you. You must hire an attorney in your state as a matter of law, in order to receive legal advise and attorney/client relationship and rights. I do not claim to be licensed to practice in the state where this information is being provided or whose law would apply, if any. My licensing credentials are noted in my profile, which you have full access to. As law is always changing, you are recommended to speak with the appropriate legal counsel for accurate and complete information. Thank you and have a great day.

Accepted Answer

Oops, yes, and specifically, you have to have had the surgery and incurred the expenses for them to be awarded, otherwise they are not yet expenses and are arguably speculative. Same with the wages, because for all he knows, you could be unemployed at that time. :)

Picture
Expert: Stephanie O. Joy, Esq.
Pos. Feedback: 99.4 %
Accepts: 1044
Answered: 6/12/2009

Managing Attorney/Lawyer

15+ Years of Legal Practice Experience: General, Soc Sec.Disability, Personal Injury, Divorce, etc.

148 days and 14 hours ago.

Reply

Thank you for your quick response.

Posted by Stephanie O. Joy, Esq. 148 days and 13 hours ago.

Answer

Very welcome. Good luck.

+
Read More

Related Legal Questions

  • My son was cited as a result of a "Terry
  • I filed a case against the city I live in.
  • my mother is in a nursing home and medicare is about to ...
  • NEW JERSEY SHERIFF SALE
  • I took an expensive drumset to a music store to sell ...
  • I have worked just under 3 months at a new ...
  • Can my landlord enter my room to show to new renter
  • I have been banned from a couple websites because of my ...



Disclaimer: Information in questions, answers, and other posts on this site ("Posts") comes from individual users, not JustAnswer; JustAnswer is not responsible for Posts. Posts are for general information, are not intended to substitute for informed professional advice (medical, legal, veterinary, financial, etc.), or to establish a professional-client relationship. The site and services are provided "as is" with no warranty or representations by JustAnswer regarding the qualifications of Experts. To see what credentials have been verified by a third-party service, please click on the "Verified" symbol in some Experts' profiles. JustAnswer is not intended or designed for EMERGENCY questions which should be directed immediately by telephone or in-person to qualified professionals.
Question List | Become an Expert | Terms of Service | Security & Privacy | About Us
© 2003-2009 JustAnswer Corp.