JustAnswer
>
Dog
Ask A Question
|
Register
|
Login
|
Help
Dog
Ask a Dog Question, Get an Answer ASAP!
Have your own Dog question?
7 Vets and Dog Experts are Online Now
characters left:
Not a Dog Question?
Question
what reasons might there be for not neutering a dog?
Submitted: 240 days and 6 hours ago.
Category: Dog
Value: $9
Status: AWAITING CUSTOMER ACTION
+
Read More
Optional Information
Age: 4; Female; Breed: dog/miniature poodle
Already Tried:
what might be reasons NOT to spay a 4 yr old dog? I am outraged by the new law in LA which would force responsible dog owners like myself to subject their dogs to unnecessary surgery (she is NEVER outside the house without being on a leash). I have a PhD and do research for a living so I think I can evaluate the evidence and the risks associated with the surgery and the long term consequences of the spaying are definitively NOT offset by the few potential benefits to the animal. anyway, while I'll join the fight against this stupid ordinance (note that I would be in favor of mandatory neutering for any dog EVER caught roaming the street)but in the meantime, I'll either find a vet who's willing to put it black on white that the surgery would not be ok for my dog, or I'll need to become a (fake) breeder. at any rate, I just wanted to know what might be good 'excuses' for not spaying a dog. if you happen to know of any vet who may be sympathetic to my predicament, please do let me know as well. THANKS!
Answer
Hello,
If a dog had ever reacted unfavorably to anesthesia in the past, that would be a medical reason not to spay her, or subject her to any elective surgery. A dog with any kind of bleeding disorder would be in the same position. Certain chronic illnesses - heart disease, kidney or liver problems, some autoimmune disorders - also would make surgery risky.
Research has been done that has shown female dogs who are aggressive/dominant tend to become more so after spaying. Female sex hormones tend to modify the aggressive behavior, and spayed dogs, of course, have less estrogen. Behaviorists recommend that such dominant or aggressive dogs not be spayed.
Other side effects of spaying, such as increased possibility of urinary incontinence developing, or poorer quality of fur wouldn't be considered reason enough not to spay.
http://www.dogsey.com/dog-articles.php?t=12202
Spayed dogs cannot be exhibited in AKC conformation shows. If you chose to enter your dog in some shows to prove she is a show dog, that may also be reason enough for a vet to exempt her.
If you need more information on the above, or have more questions, just let me know by clicking on REPLY. Good luck in your battle.
Anna
Expert:
Anna
Pos. Feedback:
98.8 %
Accepts:
Answered:
3/28/2009
Dog Expert
35 years training & showing dogs. Written articles for Dog Fancy, Dogs, Dog World.
+
Read More
Related Dog Questions
how to give injection of polyglycan in dog's hip
my dog ruby a 34lb Brittany has frequent bouts of vomiting
what is a good over the counter remedy for eye staining for
my dogs kidneys are not working as they should due to a side
I have a Brittany Spaniel that's 4 years old and alittle ove...
My Papillon of 10 years has a cysts on his back and my Vet
My 10 year old dog has been drooling excessivly and vomitted
red rash on tummy, sometimes like white head, skin black in