Hello XXXXXX,
Welcome to Just Answer.
Sorry to hear about your problem.
I don't think that flagstone will give you the "wow" factor that you are looking for, also it is expensive. Porcelain tile I wouldn't even recommend because it will not last; it is not durable enough unless you installed it on a concrete slab. Since your existing patio is rose color, I would go with a deep red brick paver. This will give you the "pop" you are looking for, it will have a nice texture, there are many patterns to choose from, it will compliment the rose color and it will be very durable and not cost you a fortune.
Click here to see examples of brick pavers and patterns.
Click here to see the brick color I think will look good; darker red if possible.
If you need further help or clarification on this answer, please do not hesitate to reply to this post.
Thanks for asking your question at Just Answer.
Best of Luck, Brian
Please leave feedback at your convenience.
I thought your answer was right on the mark. Dark red would be a great contrast. But I am having trouble finding a brick in the right color. So many of them are light red, almost pink, and then they tend to go orange.
Thank you, Joan
XXXXXX,
I cannot recall what they have at the home improvement stores; you may need to go to a landscape stone/ brick yard to find the deep red. If you decide to go with bricks rather than concrete pavers, I definitely know that you will find a deep red. A local brick supplier would carry them.
Architect
Licensed Architect- 12 years, L.E.E.D. AP, Former Remodeling Contractor- 10 years