How JustAnswer Works:
  • Ask an Expert
    Experts are full of valuable knowledge and are ready to help with any question. Credentials confirmed by a Fortune 500 verification firm.
  • Get a Professional Answer
    Via email, text message, or notification as you wait on our site.
    Ask follow up questions if you need to.
  • 100% Satisfaction Guarantee
    Rate the answer you receive.
Ask Dr. Andy Your Own Question
Dr. Andy
Dr. Andy, Medical Director
Category: Dog
Satisfied Customers: 30031
Experience:  UC Davis Graduate, Interests: Dermatology, Internal Medicine, Pain Management
Type Your Dog Question Here...
Dr. Andy is online now
A new question is answered every 9 seconds

I cant get my 5 month old, 45 pound pup to eat more than 2

This answer was rated:

I can't get my 5 month old, 45 pound pup to eat more than 2 cups a day of anything! I'm therefore looking for a very concentrated puppy food (cost doesn't matter) that will do the trick. I prefer grain free and all natural. HELP? He should get much bigger...I think he is a German Shepard, Hound, Golden mix.
Hello! My name is XXXXX XXXXX it will be my pleasure to help you with your dog today.

So is he eating 2 cups of food per feeding, or all day?

How much exercise does he get?

Does he get treats at all?

Customer: replied 3 years ago.

Two cups daily (one cup in the morning and one cup in the evening). He is not very active. He is a med-low energy pup. He doesn't get treats very often since I want him to eat more actual food. I have even tried feeding him four times daily and he will still only eat a total of 2 cups of anything.


Thanks for answering my questions. I really appreciate it.

The thing to remember is that the general rule of feeding is 1 cup per 30 pounds of body technically, a 45 pound dog could only eat 1.5 cups of food a day...or just about what he is eating.

Also, exercise increases appetite. A dog who burns a lot of energy eats although your boy is eating the right amount of food for his weight, if you'd like to prompt him to eat more, then try to encourage him to exercise more. Since he's a mellow-low energy dog, he's probably only eating what he needs to replenish the energy he uses.

Amp up the exercise and I bet he'll eat more.

As for foods....I'm a big fan of Blue Buffalo. High quality food that really seems to work for my dogs.

I hope this helps.
Customer: replied 3 years ago.

Blue Buffalo is only a 3 star food and has had too many recalls. I am writing today because I do want to go by the feeding guidelines since my pup is a little underweight.


The type of answer I am looking for is one where you do the research and look at what food has both meat (ie: chicken) and meal (ie: chicken meal). I am trying to find a four-five star food that doesn't require feeding four cups a day.


In the past I have feed Orijens and Fromm but those also require a greater quantity of food to be eaten.

I'm going to go ahead and opt out and see if another expert wants to pick this up. I've got experience with the foods in my area, but since most foods have recalls, I don't think I'm going to be able to find a food that will work for you.

Please don't respond to this, or you'll lock other experts out.
Welcome! My name isXXXXX am a 2003 graduate from UC Davis, and currently a Medical Director of a veterinary hospital.

Difficult question. I agree with you that not all foods are really created equal. Actually, neither are the pets. Let's take a very active or hyper labrador or shephered, compared to the same dog that sits around in a house all day doing nothing. Their energy "needs" the calories they need to maintain their body weights are very different.

I reviewed the previous answer and your responses. Many of these holistic diets are not necessary.

You want something researched. Agreed. Then, let's stick with a food that is clinically tested.
Science Diet foods, also known as Hills, is widely respected in the veterinary community. Some people hate it because it has corn, or meat is not the first ingredient. I can understand that. But!!!!

They have a new product line. It is called Science Diet "Ideal Balance". It does not have corn, uses quality meat products, and it is very well balanced.

Ironically, you'll still likely pay less for Ideal Balance, then you would Blue Buffalo, or these fancy holistic foods.

How much to feed. Guess what. As much as you want!!!!
What? That's crazy.

Yep. You need to weight Ruben once a month and work with your vet.
Your vet should evaluate her and establish her current body score, as to determine how much underweight she may be.
But, if we determine 2 cups a day is what she needs to maintain and gain just a bit, than its 2 cups. if it happens to be 4 or 5 cups, than that's the number.

Don't worry about the guidelines on the bag!! It is only a starting guideline, but please, work with your vet to keep assessing her weight regularly. Too fast of growth is not ideal either for the bone structure.
Ideal Balance by Hill's

One last thing:
Make sure a fecal test has been done. Even if it was alredy done, I would encourage repeating one more time.

Bring in a fresh poop sample to the veterinarian. Ideally, within a few hours. Request that it be sent “OUT” to the laboratory instead of being looked at in the hospital (more accurate that way). We are not interested in only worm eggs, but also checking for the very common microscopic bugs like giardia and coccidia. These types of parasites will not be cured with over-the-counter dewormers. Giardia can also be difficult to identify on routine fecal tests, so ask your vet if they always add a “giardia elisa” to the fecal test. Here is more detailed information about fecal testing:
Fecal Testing

I would hate for something as silly as a giardia infection to be the cause of poor weight gain, even if there is no diarrhea.

Hope that information has been helpful.
Please remember to select Reply to Expert, if for any reason you need further clarification, have more questions, or were expecting a different type of answer. Prior to leaving a feedback rating, which I greatly appreciate, my goal is to provide you the best answer possible.
Dr. Andy

Dr. Andy, Medical Director
Category: Dog
Satisfied Customers: 30031
Experience: UC Davis Graduate, Interests: Dermatology, Internal Medicine, Pain Management
Dr. Andy and other Dog Specialists are ready to help you