How JustAnswer Works:

  • Ask an Expert
    Experts are full of valuable knowledge and are ready to help with any question. Credentials confirmed by a Fortune 500 verification firm.
  • Get a Professional Answer
    Via email, text message, or notification as you wait on our site.
    Ask follow up questions if you need to.
  • 100% Satisfaction Guarantee
    Rate the answer you receive.

Ask Charlene Hertzberg Your Own Question

Charlene Hertzberg
Charlene Hertzberg, Child care provider, parent, teache
Category: Parenting
Satisfied Customers: 44
Experience:  22 years of experience working with children, formerly worked as a parental advisor
Type Your Parenting Question Here...
Charlene Hertzberg is online now
A new question is answered every 9 seconds

brother molesting his sister

This answer was rated:

I have a SERIOUS problem. I just caught my son red handed with his pants down, w an erection last night, with his sister in bed with him, and her pajamas unzipped. He is 11 and she is 6. I kept him in my room all night. I told him what he was doing is EXTREMELY WRONG, and NOT ok. Today after coming home from work I sat them down seperatly to ask questions. All he would say is she was tryin to tell me something, and nothing happened. She told me he makes her touch him, and in turn he touchs her. She also said she tells him NO and trys to get away but he grabs her hard. She said she was scared she would be in trouble, when I asked why didn''t she scream or tell me. I have no IDEA what I should do!!! I''m mortified, scared, and worried for both of them. What do I do. I work full time, and he is getting out of control lately. The father is not involved. Has no respect for my boyfriend or anyone. I told him I was going to put him into bootcamp if he doesn''t stop all of his stuff. Help me.....

What a terrible position you find yourself in. The needs of your children are conflicting, and both of them are very much in need of your help. There are things you can do.

First of all, you need to make sure your daughter is safe, that means that you'll have to set rules that they are not to be alone together at all. If you are not in the house, then you'll need to make sure that she is being cared for in a place seperate from her brother. At night, when you sleep, I would recommend that you put a lock on her door, you keep one key, she can have one.

Second, you need to talk with your daughter, letter he know that you will not be mad at her, and that if he, or anyone else ever touches her or does anything else that makes her feel frightened that she should tell you so that you can make sure she's okay.

Next, you need to get counseling for both children. They could go to the same counselor, but not together at the same time. Your daughter is going to have to work through what she's been through. Your son needs a chance to work through his own issues. He is still very much a little boy. He may just be exploring sexually, or he may be acting out because something has happened to him. A therapist could also help you work through the other behavior issues that he is having. If you can't afford therapy, there are many therapists who will work on a sliding scale, and there are also a lot of organizations that will help.

While you may need to change things for a little while to protect your daughter, try not to make your son feeling like there is something wrong with him, or that he is in some way "evil". That will just compound your problems. Treat it as a mistake that he made. If you treat him like he is bad, he'll live up to your expectations.

I hope that helps, if you have any further questions, please don't hesitate to hit reply.

If this answer has helped you, please remember to push the green accept button.


Charlene Hertzberg and other Parenting Specialists are ready to help you
Customer: replied 8 years ago.
So how do I handle a child that is acting as if he has no cares in the world? He says he doesn't care about everything. I have to fight with him tooth and nail to just get up and walk normally. This all happens when he doesn't get his way. As long as we ask nothing of him, and he gets to play video games he's usually good. Which I have been keeping from him latly. I told him I was going to be taking him to see a counselor, and he said he refuses to talk to them. I will take them both for therepy thou. Thank you very much.....

As far as the therapist goes, a good child therapist will be used to working with kids who aren't so sure they want to be there.

As for the discipline, the most effective method of discipline I've heard of for kids that age (and I used to teach 6th grade, so I know that age well) is as follows (it may seem harsh, but if you don't catch his attention now it will only get harder):

Step 1: Warning, explain to him that all of the things below are going to happen if he doesn't get his act together (be specific about exactly what he is doing that needs to change).

Step 2: (if the warning doesn't work, sometimes that is all that is necessary)

Remove EVERYTHING from his room and his belonging with the exception of the following:

- his bed

- a place to study if he has one (such as a desk or table)

- a light

- an alarm clock if he uses one, unless it has a radio

- a set of sheets

- one or two outfits, of your choosing

- school books and a book or so to entertain himself with

He loses all priviledges, he has no TV priviledges, he may not have anything in his room that you do not specifically approve of. He can not go out with friends or have friends in. He must come out and sit with the family for meals, and any other time you ask for his presence, otherwise, he is to remain in his room. The only person he can have in your room is yourself (your boyfriend would be okay too, if you are comfortable with that). He remains in this stage for 1 week, during which time he must prove that he is ready to regain a priviledge. If all goes well at the end of that week, he can have one item back (you can choose or you can agree together as to what that will be).

He gets that item back for the weekend. If you still feel that he is putting in his full effort at the end of the weekend, he is allowed to keep the item . If he slacks back off, it gets removed.

Step 3: He continues like this, regaining one priviledge a week. (you may decide after a set amount of time, perhaps a month, that he can have a group of priviledges back such as free roam of the house, friend priviledges, etc. If at anytime he reverts back to his old behavior he loses the most recent priviledges that were added and gets no new priviledges for two weeks. If it still continues, everything comes back out, and he has to re-earn his things back.

By the time he is back up to having all of his priviledges, behaving will be a habit. I've seen this work for kids whose parents and teachers were beginning to feel like it was hopeless.


Charlene Hertzberg and other Parenting Specialists are ready to help you
Customer: replied 8 years ago.
Thank you very much...I will try this method.

Your welcome. Do give him the warning first though, sometimes just hearing it is enough to scare them to their senses. Essentially what you're doing is boot camp at home.


Related Parenting Questions