Sorry I took so long... had some trouble shrinking down the photo sizes.
The weird thing is before I took this fuel sample I took a sample with the key in just the "on" position to make sure I hooked up the fuel pump properly. The fuel I got from that was clear with a little yellow tinge to it way nicer than this sample. Now when I crank the engine the fuel comes out like this. I don't think it's the fuel tank because when I removed the fuel pump assembly I looked inside the tank and the fuel looked clear and I didn't see anything out of the ordinary.