Ask a Neurologist. Get Answers to Your Neurology Questions.
It is likely that you have had nerve injury (probably to the superior orbital nerve) that is secondary to the teeth extraction.
You would need to go to a neurologist and get this diagnosis confirmed.
Generally speaking, nerve tonic like Pregabalin and possibly some steroid (to reduce inflammation) should be useful after discussing with neurologist,
As far as I can see, some of the symptoms can be explained due to excessive anxiety as well, especially tingling numbness in hands,
I agree that a neurologist opinion would be helpful in this situation to confirm the exact cause,
Dr. Gupta, MD