Hi! I believe I can be of help with this issue.
First, let me say I am so very impressed with your writing this question and trying to find the right way to help your daughter. So many parents of teens who are driven to succeed feed that one-dimensional drivenness in their child. You seem to recognize your daughter to be a WHOLE human being and are concerned with her welfare. I just want you to know how beautiful that is, because I've seen the damage that sometimes can be caused by the other way of parenting. So, good for you!
Okay. You know, I was wondering how to approach the idea of overdeveloped intellectual side and underdeveloped emotional side. But then at the end you made it easy for me: you wrote, "he does have a boy friend, it's a very young relationship. They talk baby talk to each other."
Let's face it, this relationship isn't just young, it's infantile. It is two kids who are struggling to deal with emotional reality of human life and have no clue. Because, at least for her, her intellectual side is so dominant. She's an only child, very smart, and used to being an adult in her thinking---probably from when she was child.
And this is expressed in her wanting medication: give me a pill and make the problem go away. But the problem is not that there is some chemical imbalance. The problem is that she is a whole human being and needs to learn to develop her emotional maturity and her emotional self. And by the way, there ARE NO meds for chemistry and algebra!
I think if you can afford it, then a psychologist or psychotherapist can help her a LOT. The therapy needs to be with the goal of emotional development: feeling good about herself as an average student in math and science, identifying her emotions, and expressing them.
The school counselor may be able to identify a psychologist or therapist who has this humanistic orientation. Or a clergyman might be able to help. But interview the psychologist first and make sure that you are confident in his/her orientation and values and experience.
Again, the goal here is to develop your daughter's ability to be a whole human being and not only to see herself as her success or failure in a very narrow range of life.
I wish you the very best!
Please remember to click the green accept button. Feel free to continue the discussion; my goal is to get you the best answers possible. Bonuses are always appreciated! If I can be of further help with any issue, just put "for Dr. Mark" in the front of your new question, and I'll be the one to answer it. All the best, XXXXX XXXXX