Hello I am a licensed attorney. I am here to help answer your questions. Please do not hesitate to ask for clarification
How long have you lived in AZ?
Did you file a recent AZ tax return?
My lease agreement begins 10/2012.
We haven't filed a 2012 return yet (extension).
My income was considered TX from July-Dec 2012 because I had a direct-deposit into TX acct (my parents live there and I have been helping out w/ care and wanted a local bank).
in 2012, Jan-July my income was considered Colorado (which is where I have lived since 2000)
My son is a dependent and we claim him as one on our return....just haven't done the 2012 one yet.
I just feel like I'm getting some generic "no" and wonder if there really IS no recourse?
Under U of AZ residency law
2. REQUIREMENTS FOR RESIDENT STATUS
a) The general rule is that in order to obtain resident status for tuition purposes, a student must establish his or her domicile in Arizona at least one year immediately prior to the last day of regular registration for the semester in which the student proposes to attend the university. Arizona domicile occurs when a financially independent person is physically present in Arizona with the intention of making Arizona his or her permanent home.
It seems the 12 months requirement is the main issue,
if you read down to this:
e) There are certain exceptions to the general rule. A student may also be eligible for resident status if he or she can establish that, on or before the last day of regular registration, he or she meets one of the following criteria:
i. DEPENDENT The student is domiciled in Arizona and has not met the one year durational requirement, but the student’s parent(s) are domiciled in this state and are entitled to claim him or her as a dependent for state and federal tax purposes
it would seem that my "domicile" simply must be "in state"....or am I just mis-reading this?
when I go to the definition on maricopa county, this is their definition of domicile:
Domicile" means a person's true, fixed and permanent home and place of habitation. It is the place where he intends to remain and to which he expects to return when he leaves without intending to establish a new domicile elsewhere.
The exception may apply, however if you did not have the AZ tax returns it would be difficult to prove domicile,
this just seems a little subjective, don't you think....
This is a common issue,
I would file a late or amended tax return,
and claim him as a dependant,
and file the appeal with the tax return information as evidence of domicile at the time of registration,
I won't have AZ income until 2013 anyway, because my w-2 for work has my address in TX (or does that matter?)
My accountant is great----would she be within the law to put it as AZ income from 10/12 even though the w-2 has TX?
if you actually lived in AZ,
in 2012, the income should be taxed in AZ as that would be your place of residence,
and that would help you obtain and establish residenc
Even though I didn't have an AZ drivers license at that time or an AZ bank acct? I didn't get those until 2013 (because I didn't realize that I needed them---my son was planning on going to University of CO
yes, but you have to establish you lived in AZ,
I would discuss the issue of paying and filing an AZ tax return,
as you were a resident in AZ,
if you cannot claim this for 2012,
you would have to wait till next year to have your son be declared a resident
wouldn't you think a lease agreement should suffice to establish I lived there? He said my documentation looked "suspicious" which just sounded ridiculous---like he was going to reject me no matter what.
He said my son would have to prove total independence from us to be able to apply for it---which is not possible (he's a freshman in college....he can barely do anything independently)
a lease is not an official document, a tax return is usually required and would be the most significant form to establish residency
OK, I don't need to amend, since we havent filed one yet.It just feels like no matter WHAT we provide, they are the ones making the call.....and they have no incentive to say "yes"
Is there anything else we can provide in addition to what I have already?
It seems you have provided a significant amount already, your best option is to discuss the matter with your accountant, and see if she can file an AZ return, when you lived in the State in 2012
That would be the best evidence, and most likely what they want to see
OK, I will. I just don't know how to prove anything is my "permanent home and place of habitation"----because I am still married and my husband and daughter still live in Colorado and I am there frequently when I'm not flying.
tax returns is key,
What about this "cut all ties" thing? I simply cannot do that to their satisfaction if that is truly the letter of the law as the guy said. IS that true???
Because I also own property in TX and have a bank acct there as well....it just makes no sens.
the only other option is to have him declare as financially independent,
and not claim him as a dependant,
however that will be difficult as you cannot claim any deduction for him,
My income isn't so high that I actually NEED a deduction for him :)
But we (his father and me) are not paying for his college---it is covered by a college plan set up by his grandparents.
So we don't think we'll be able to claim his a dependent going forward...
that may be an option,
however, I would first explore trying to declare last years income as AZ income as you were a resident of AZ in 2012,
the place of direct deposit should not be the determinative factor,
OK, good! So even though it went to a TX acct---it can be claimed as AZ income (from Oct-Dec).
I will try that----thanks! Any other ideas???
not at this point, make sure you have a AZ bank account as well,
I am just concerned by their definition of domicile being a place where I intend to remain and expect to return----because my husband is staying in Colorado and we have no intention of divorcing or splitting up our property
Yes, I have an AZ bank acct.
that is difficult,
you may have to file a separate return, so you do not show the fathers residence,
good idea. glad we filed the extension!
your accountant should help you with this,
Good luck, and if you have any further questions please do not hesitate to ask.
If satisfied please provide us with positive feedback, thank you
thank you so much!!! can I get a copy of this?
yes, I'll give good feedback!
yes, it will be emailed to you,
if you have any further questions please do not hesitate to ask.
Once you provide positive feedback, I can send the chat through email,
DISCLAIMER: Answers from Experts on JustAnswer are not substitutes for the advice of an attorney. JustAnswer is a public forum and questions and responses are not private or confidential or protected by the attorney-client privilege. The Expert above is not your attorney, and the response above is not legal advice. You should not read this response to propose specific action or address specific circumstances, but only to give you a sense of general principles of law that might affect the situation you describe. Application of these general principles to particular circumstances must be done by a lawyer who has spoken with you in confidence, learned all relevant information, and explored various options. Before acting on these general principles, you should hire a lawyer licensed to practice law in the jurisdiction to which your question pertains.
The responses above are from individual Experts, not JustAnswer. The site and services are provided “as is”. To view the verified credential of an Expert, click on the “Verified” symbol in the Expert’s profile. This site is not for emergency questions which should be directed immediately by telephone or in-person to qualified professionals. Please carefully read the Terms of Service (last updated February 8, 2012).