Have Legal Questions? Ask a Lawyer Now.
I am now being made aware of the changes. A smoking law was pasted some time ago, about 6 mo ago in public places. The owners are now demanding that I sigh a No-Smoking Policy-Lease Addendum ; that I feel uncomfortable signing. I smell bacon.
Thank you for your follow-up.If you had no idea in the past that this was a violation, it is tough for the complex to hold you accountable in a retroactive manner. There has to be some notice to you, in writing preferably, showing that a new change was passed pertaining to your home. If there is no evidence of notice, then notice starts from the date you were made aware of the changes. But please be advised that going forward a complex can change the regulation and if you fail to comply, then that would be a valid ground for eviction. They cannot make you sign the addendum to your existing lease, but they can likewise choose to not renew your lease going forward and serve you with a notice to quit the premises.Good luck.
The lease has no expiration date that I know of. They just today gave me a notice of their smoke free policy.
Thank you for your follow-up. That actually hurts you. Most leases do expire as they are year to year if signed. If unsigned, then the law treats the lease to be 'month-to-month', and that means that the landlord can give 30 days advance notice to any changes. Then, if he changes are not signed or ignored, he could deem it to be a violation of the next period's lease that is now modified with this new language.Good luck.
I smell bacon. Studies show high temp cooking are more harmful than cigarette smoke. I can see I might be forced to move, to another state because other options in this area will not be affordable. Where can I get assistance? .
My apologies but what does "I smell bacon" mean?I am trying to respectfully XXXXX XXXXX any regulation, regardless of how legitimate or stupid is passed, it is still valid. There are some studies, for example, that show speeding is safer than not speeding, but that does not inherently violate speeding limits. The fact high temp cooking may be more dangerous would not invalidate the regulation. The best argument here may be to claim that if the landlord has no ventilation then his claim to you is likewise invalid, but there is no guarantee that this argument would prevail.I do appreciate your negative rating, as I personally had something to do with your situation. Please be well.
It is agreed that the. Laws are for the handicapped. Just because someone cannot drive around a curve at 35mph, and we do fine at 55mph, we should all drive the gimp rate of 35mph to be equalled. I still smell bacon, studies show that there are more carsoniogens that caused cancer than cigarette smoke. Im a handy cap here, wheres my equil protection here. Or do we have selective enforcement?
It is a learning experience for the both of us. I am not satisfide at this point in time. Hopefully we may learn somthing. I really appreciate your efforts. Thanks Ritch
Ritch,In that case I would ask that you hold off rating until our communication comes to a close as each time you rate, especially negatively, it impacts my ability to remain being able to reply to answers or provide further service.As for your question, my apologies but being 'handicapped' does not grant you greater rights than someone who isn't handicapped. Using the speeding example, if the speed limit states 55, the fact that you are impaired does not grant you the right to go 10 miles over. Furthermore this is a PRIVATE rule that the landlord is imposing--if they want to impose a rule that does not violate state law and they provide timely notice, then you either have to honor the changes, negotiate a compromise, or leave the home. This isn't your property, it is the landlord's, and the landlord can impose rules or regulations on tenants. For example a landlord can impose a rule forbidding pets on premises, or imposes rules demanding that anyone staying overnight be first vetted and approved by the landlord. Those are all privileges that a real owner of the home can take for granted for himself, but as this is a tenancy, a tenant can be limited provided those limitations are provided in advance. What you are seeking is not equal protection but greater protection on account that you are handicapped, and that does not work that way. Good luck.
I agree to your terms. This is my home we are talking about. I mind my own business and expect to be left alone. Now I feel a cold nose in my butt.I smell bacon, car exost......etc, radone. I need equil protection of the stupid man law. Im handicapped.
I am sorry but I do not understand what you mean. If you are renting, then this is not 'your' home, not really. It is the landlord's, who can choose to modify conditions under which you rent, including adding addendums or modifying your rent, to name a few. If you feel that the regulation is unfair appeal to the landlord and ask for defiant terms, but it would be up to the landlord to grant--he is not required to grant you this simply because you are handicapped. He may be legally required to make his entrance ADA compliant, but nowhere is smoking listed as a disability or as some sort of a protected status where you would be entitled to something more. I realize my answer is likely unwelcome but I cannot in good conscience tell you a different answer if that answer happens to be incorrect.Please be well.
I'm sorry. I'm not very pleased. You said it is not my home because I'm renting , I disagree. It is my home because I reside there and make it such. I may not be the owner of the building but the apartment I reside in is my home. And if push comes to shove I think I would be within my rights in some cases. What I ment by I smell bacon. As I see it smoke is smoke ,why single me out while others may smoke up the building in other ways and be left alone. As far as ownership goes the entity collecting the property tax is the real owner. Every one else thinks they own their property, and they are no less a renter than I.
I am not claiming the property I reside at as mine. However I do have property within my leagle residents for over 8 years that is in my name.And now they want to change ower agreement to fit most likely a majority or a minority or possibly a single interest.
And thats it? And when evicted ....I not only disagree with managements decision, I disagree with alot of others that are depriving of my liberties.
You like the other have not learned me somthing I did not know. Thanks
Unfortunately I can expect the kangaroos court decisions. Not in my favor of course. There is another way I think, just need to think out of the Jerry riged box.
You are telling me nothing I do not already know.That is not my way . I hear the news. What else.?
That last statement was false. An attorney cannot run for an office, on there own merits in the state of North Dakota. The ellections are Jerry rigged. Back to the smoking issue. I do not think licensed attorney's are representing the smokers in a right full way. Thay are stacking the deck.
DISCLAIMER: Answers from Experts on JustAnswer are not substitutes for the advice of an attorney. JustAnswer is a public forum and questions and responses are not private or confidential or protected by the attorney-client privilege. The Expert above is not your attorney, and the response above is not legal advice. You should not read this response to propose specific action or address specific circumstances, but only to give you a sense of general principles of law that might affect the situation you describe. Application of these general principles to particular circumstances must be done by a lawyer who has spoken with you in confidence, learned all relevant information, and explored various options. Before acting on these general principles, you should hire a lawyer licensed to practice law in the jurisdiction to which your question pertains.
The responses above are from individual Experts, not JustAnswer. The site and services are provided “as is”. To view the verified credential of an Expert, click on the “Verified” symbol in the Expert’s profile. This site is not for emergency questions which should be directed immediately by telephone or in-person to qualified professionals. Please carefully read the Terms of Service (last updated February 8, 2012).