Thank you for choosing Just Answer.
First of all the cashing of the check would not be a criminal matter because the intent to defraud or otherwise cheat California Check Cashing was not there. Get the $1800.00 from TD, the money must still be there to pay CCC, if a stop payment was made. If the check cashing has added some fees these should be paid by TD . You just need to get a statement showing the fees from Check cashing and show to TD Ameritrade.
You should get a letter from Ameritrade indicating the stop payment was incorrectly processed and that there were adequate funds in the account when the check was issued. Keep a copy, take a copy to California Check Cashing. if a police report is made, show them the letter make sure you keep a copy if they ask for it.
TD Ameritrade is only liable for the excess fees. You are liable to repay the $1800.00 because you received $1800.00 . The original $1800 should still be in your account if the check bounced..
Please remember the to click on OK, GOOD or EXCELLENT SERVICE so I may get credit form my answer. If you have further questions please ask. Thank You !
Thanks Jack! This happened about a month ago, and I've already spent the money. I only found out about the stop payment recently, and spoke with a representative from TD Ameritrade yesterday who told me that it was highly unusual that they stopped payment on the check that was issued to me. It seems the funds were there to cover the check - and then given other items came through - they weren't there - so I'm guessing that's why they stopped payment. TD Ameritrade is online only, the check that was issued to me was out of state, and TD Ameritrade doesn't send statements out, and couldn't give me more information as to why. The botXXXXX XXXXXne is -- I know I'm resposible to repay California Check Cashing - however, given the circumstances, and it being so long ago, I want to make a payment arrangement with California Check Cashing, but they tell me they don't accept payment arrangements, and if I don't pay them back by April 19th - they will file a police report. Do I have any remedy? Should I be concerned once the police report is filed that I could be arrested or have to appear in court on this? I can only afford a payment arrangement to pay these funds back - and yet California Check Cashing will not allow me to do so - and wants the amount in full by April 19th. What can the police do? What remedy do I have? Mike
Hello,Different contributor here. Please permit me to assist. First, California has two different bad check laws. A civil law, and a criminal law. The civil law provides penalties for failure to satisfy the insufficient funds check in a timely manner. The law is very complex. See this link for a detailed explanation. However, you don't really need a detailed explanation. The botXXXXX XXXXXne is that if you don't pay the check, then your penalties will start to mount up and you will get stuck in the mud with a huge debt. So, you need to get the money from TD Ameritrade, and pay the check cashing service so you can get rid of that part of the problem. Concerning the service reporting you to the police, Penal Code 476a provides that it may be prosecuted as a felony to pass a check in an amount of $450 or more. However, to prevail, the district attorney must prove that you intended to pass the check with insufficient funds, and since you presumably could prove that it was a problem of the investment institution, then that would avoid the criminal conviction. But, it won't stop the police from arresting you and charging you with the crime, and that means you will have to go through the criminal justice system which would cost a lot of unnecessary time and money. So, once again, you need to get the money and pay the check cashing service. Once you have done that, you can demand that TD Ameritrade pay all of your penalty fees that you had to pay the check cashing service. If they refuse, then you will have to demand arbitration (because TD Ameritrade customer agreements have an arbitration clause, so you cannot sue in court). If you can show that the account had sufficient funds, and the check was stopped due to an error by TD Ameritrade, then the arbitrator will order TD Ameritrade to pay you -- and to pay your arbitration costs. Hopefully, that would be the end of the matter. Alternatively, you can file a complaint with FINRA. If the error is as cut and dried as you describe, FINRA can force TD Ameritrade to pay you, or risk losing its brokerage license (which would be ridiculous, given the small amount of money at stake). Those are the options. Hope this helps.
Thanks Socrateaser! Let me just ask three more questions to get complete with this:
1) Just to recap - the check in question cashed by me at California Check Cashing was NOTa personal check I wrote from my checkbook - RATHER a check issued to me FROM TD Ameritrade. So the check was drafted "pay to the order of me" -- and it was from TD Ameritrade. (Not sure if that makes a difference or not). I think that's called a third party check. It would be along the same lines as if I had cashed a payroll check - and then my employer stopped payment. Or something like that. While it is true that the check was paid to me and drafted to me by my instruction to the bank, and my account at the time did have funds in it. I just want to make sure you know that the check was not a personal check - rather a check from TD Ameritrade made out to me.
2) The check was drawn out of state - TD Ameritrade's checks are out of state checks. I read somewhere that affects the way it can be collected or not collected and makes a difference according to California law I think?
3) Even though California Check Cashing has given me an ultimatum of paying the check no later than April 19th or they will go to the police and file a police report - don't I have any remedy to ask to pay by April 30th instead? Mike
Thank you SO VERY much! I will do my best to negotiate a later payment date, and either way -- I will pay the debt by the due date to avoid the possible consequences you listed above. Many thanks again!
DISCLAIMER: Answers from Experts on JustAnswer are not substitutes for the advice of an attorney. JustAnswer is a public forum and questions and responses are not private or confidential or protected by the attorney-client privilege. The Expert above is not your attorney, and the response above is not legal advice. You should not read this response to propose specific action or address specific circumstances, but only to give you a sense of general principles of law that might affect the situation you describe. Application of these general principles to particular circumstances must be done by a lawyer who has spoken with you in confidence, learned all relevant information, and explored various options. Before acting on these general principles, you should hire a lawyer licensed to practice law in the jurisdiction to which your question pertains.
The responses above are from individual Experts, not JustAnswer. The site and services are provided “as is”. To view the verified credential of an Expert, click on the “Verified” symbol in the Expert’s profile. This site is not for emergency questions which should be directed immediately by telephone or in-person to qualified professionals. Please carefully read the Terms of Service (last updated February 8, 2012).