Have Legal Questions? Ask a Lawyer Now.
Clearly, the acts you are describing are not themselves illegal.
In order to be prostitution, there must be sexual activity involved.
Sexual activity must include contact between genitals and other body parts. Basically, if you would consider it sex and you are doing it for money, it is illegal.
What you've described is far less than what goes on in gentleman's clubs every day.
Also, I assume there will be no nudity involved.
As far as taxes are concerned, it really depends on how your business or organized (i.e. an LLP, Inc, etc.).
I assume it will simply be a sole proprietorship, which is the simplest in regards XXXXX XXXXX Basically, you would be required to pay taxes on everything you bring in and it would be taxed at your marginal rate, but you would have the opportunity for multiple deductions. You really should consult with an account about tax specific questions. Just Answer has a forum for tax experts.
I hope that answers your question. If not, feel free to ask follow up questions. If so, please click the ACCEPT button. Good luck.
I guess I was checking because I saw that in PA "sadomasochistic abuse" was considered a form of prostitution. I'm not sure if this information was accurate or not. To me, having someone touch my feet fully clothed is not abuse as I'm not hitting anyone. I just want to make sure I'm not straying from the gray area.
That is the reason I inquired.
So it varies I guess what people consider sexual activity, but to me, even if that is adult, it is not sexual activity. I'm nervous to go forward with it because I want to have a career and such
Yes, so long as it is not sexually explicit, you will not be doing anything illegal.
That's good to know. I guess the only thing I have to figure out now is how to pay my taxes. Which leads me to another question :P If I am still allowed to ask.
There are some states that criminalize sadomasochistic activities, but I do not see where Pennsylvania is one of them.
Oh, because I website told me that it did. But foot fetish is a unique activity.
Either way, what you've described does not fall within that description.
How can I pay my taxes without showing exactly what I'm doing in detail. If someone were to do a background check, I wouldn't want them to see I did foot fetish sessions. It would be weird to some people.
Like, I personally could care less. . but I know how some people are close minded to certain things.
People pay for foot massages on a regular basis. I know what you are doing is different, but any law that would criminalize what you do would have to be so vague that it would criminalize things not intended to be illegal.
The form you file with the IRS does not say exactly what you do. You could be as vague as "personal services."
Yeah like, how could you throw someone in jail for allowing someone to massage your feet and worship them for money? I didn't even think I needed to ask a lawyer
But I'm so careful about my future since I want to be a psychologist, that I wanted to go the extra mile and do so
I understand. You are right to be careful.
As far as details on the taxes question, those may be best directed at an accountant, which are available on Just Answer, too.
I will eventually get to an accountant. I know this says that this isn't legitimate legal advice, but do you in good faith say that I should be fine doing foot fetish sessions and having a client pay me for them? I know that you can't literally say yes to this but it seems like you're extremely sure since you are a lawyer and all
and this is such a tame service
I can say that, in my opinion, it is not illegal under any state law that I am aware of. If it were, I would think the law would have Constitutional challenges.
In short, you will be OK.
Also, this is not the type of activity target by law enforcement, especially in the lean times we are in.
I clearly state in my ads that there's nothing bad going on. Just foot fetish. I also make sure my clients understand that. If it were targeted by law enforcement, woudln't that eliminate me as someone suspcious?
I mean if you post an ad like "xoxo girl ready 4 u" vs, "Offering legal Foot Worshipping Sessions" I feel like they'd go more for the other one
maybe I'm just overly cautious. either way, so far I am satisfied with my answers
They would, but so long as you aren't engaged in sexual activity, it wouldn't matter if they did target you.
I understand. It isn't something to take lightly, but you will be OK.
it seems that you're saying that it would actually cause issues if foot fetish were deemed problems that it could cause civil rights issues like "why can't somone touch my feet if I want them to?" or "he was just masaging my feet" So it would make no sense for that to be an issue.
which makes sense because sadomasochism is only illegal in certain places because it's considered assualt and you can actually slap a label on it
Exactly. In order for a statute to be Constitutional, it must not be over broad. Basically, a statute is over broad if it criminalizes things that are clearly not meant to be illegal.
I apologize for my poor sentence structure. I've been studying for a test all night lol
For example, there was a recent Supreme Court case dealing with a federal law which criminalized videos depicting animal abuse (from what I gather, there is a fetish market for people who enjoy watching small animals stomped to death).
You see, I do foot fetish because you deal with far less crazy people
Yes, unfortunately there is a market for that.
The Supreme Court said it was over broad because it criminalized things which are clearly not criminal (i.e. videos showing animal slaughter, etc.).
So this isn't abuse because I'm just havign my feet worshipped. The worst I'd do is roleplay, like order someone to worship my feet...but if that were deemed wrong it could actually affect freedom of speech. So I see what you're saying. Issue is I don't know how laws are formed so I don't understand what can be said and what cant
You will be fine so long as there is no sex or sadomasochistic abuse (anything that could be characterized as assault).
Even roleplay wouldn't be assault, correct? lol
Or considered mental abuse?
Because well, with foot fetish some of it is insulting the dude and calling him "a foot worshipping pig" . . . I can't explain more without making one or both of us laugh
It must be physical. When the other person is consenting it gets into a grey area. You can hurt feelings all you want. Words can NEVER be the basis for an assault claim.
That's what I thought too lol
I actually used to want to be a lawyer
But I chose psych because I was more interested in the mind and such
There's more honor in having people lick your feet.
Exactly. it's like, people might not consider this an honorable job.
But I'm not lying to anyone
or ripping anyone off
or being fake, at all. And most "honorable" jobs have the most corruption
In your proposed business, everyone gets what they want. In mine, half the people leave mad.
Well I'm sorry if I'm not supposed to actually talk to you
I went to a law firm
it would have costed me 2000 dollars to answer this question
They had to do "research" for at least four hours
They think I'm stupid because I'm 20.
They wanted to set up an LLC for me too. Can I do foot sessions for now and keep track of my money without setting up a trademark?
Have I answered your questions?
You have, and you also made me and my room mates crack up with the honor comment. That was awesome.
I'm totally satisfied.
Thank you very much. I shall give you credit and rate you.
Great. Good luck.
DISCLAIMER: Answers from Experts on JustAnswer are not substitutes for the advice of an attorney. JustAnswer is a public forum and questions and responses are not private or confidential or protected by the attorney-client privilege. The Expert above is not your attorney, and the response above is not legal advice. You should not read this response to propose specific action or address specific circumstances, but only to give you a sense of general principles of law that might affect the situation you describe. Application of these general principles to particular circumstances must be done by a lawyer who has spoken with you in confidence, learned all relevant information, and explored various options. Before acting on these general principles, you should hire a lawyer licensed to practice law in the jurisdiction to which your question pertains.
The responses above are from individual Experts, not JustAnswer. The site and services are provided “as is”. To view the verified credential of an Expert, click on the “Verified” symbol in the Expert’s profile. This site is not for emergency questions which should be directed immediately by telephone or in-person to qualified professionals. Please carefully read the Terms of Service (last updated February 8, 2012).