Intellectual Property Law
Intellectual Property Law Questions? Ask a Lawyer
i have a website for an online game and i sell its currency and some accounts(characters) i have received an email from the company of the game saying that i violated the tos and copyrights. so my web host provider disabled my website now i switched to chinese web hosting. my question is can they sue me knowing that i live in kuwait and they are located in canada.
Yes, they could try to pursue a case but they would have a hard time enforcing you as they have a jurisdictional issue (i.e. they do not have jurisdiction to compel you to come to Canada for a suit).
If you continue to violate their TOS, they will continually shut you down and try to block you from using the site.
ok but i don't have anything with my name
domain and the host are all registered to a chinese company
and the chinese company told me that they will not disable my website if they received any email from the company
The answer to those questions are of a technical nature, not a legal nature.
i understand ...ok so what just happend is that they just tried to buy something from my website
I am not sure the technicality of how they could find your information through your domain or host. And I cannot comment as to whether or not your host will disable your site
and i refunded them and canceled their order
do you think they are trying to get my information from my paypal or they just want an evidence that i sold them this item
Depending on their TOS they could try to sue you in your own country under your country's civil law. However, that may be somewhat difficult and since they do not know your personal information, it would seem it would be extremely hard.
can paypal give them my info?
Hard to say. It could be both. I do know that paypal has registered information but they cannot give your information unless they are compelled to do so by law.
ok i have questions about that copyrights now
i don't use the game name or logo in my website ....
Here is where paypal could give out your info "
so lets say if the game name is XXXXX XXXXX warcraft or "wow" and my domain is wnw n as and is that a violating to copyrights?
Just to be clear you said that your domain is wnwn?
because in the email they say that my website is acting as the offical support site for the game
In the example that you just gave, no, that is not violating trademarks. And domain name usage is a trademark issue, not copyright
It is likely that the issue is not the domain name of your site but the activity on it - i.e. what you are selling
yes if the game name is XXXXX XXXXX of war craft" and my domain is "wnw" or wnwstore
No, the domain would not infringe upon their trademark.
ok what about some pictures from the game is that a violation?
not that logo
just some picture of characters
Yes, that would be a copyright violation.
All images, characters, etc. from the game are copyright protected.
but ur saying if they want to sue me they will have to come to my country to do that
and comply to our rules
Yes. They could sue in their home country but they cannot compel you to go there for the suit and they would need to serve you. However, if you ever go to that country, they could potentially serve you.
well im not canadian and i don't plan to go there
The main thing that they will try to do is shut you down through your host, as you already know.
so what do u advice me to do? ignore their emails or just remove everything related to copyright?
im sure they can't shutdown my website
because there are other website that are using the game name and logo for years and they are located in china
You should comply with their TOS. I would remove all infringing content such as copyright images, etc.
It may be that they tried to shut down those sites as well. Or perhaps they just ignored them.
do u think thats why they just tried to order an item from me ? to prove that i violated the tos?
Probably that and to find out your name and information.
i mean if i sell a character to someone they cant prove that i did
trading gold is a part of the game
That I am not sure about because it would again be of a technical nature. I am not even sure how you can "sell a character'
With games such as WOW they can cancel someone's account for any reason. They will try to discover who you are to cancel your account with the game.
i think its selling the login and the password XXXXX mean they still own the character and they can delete ban or whatever at anytime
Oh so you create a user and password XXXXX then sell the account?
thats not stealing anything from them its only a violation to tos
and they can prove that
Interesting. They could shut down any account if they know if violated their TOS. Your website and they selling of accounts surely violates their terms but that is not actionable except for shutting down your account. Their main cause of action would be based on copyright infringement for your external website.
They technically could sue for any amounts that you obtained in the sale as it would be their damages in your selling the character - but I assume that is somewhat nominal. Copyright infringement is the bigger issue.
ok the only copyright violation i have right now are the pictures on the character i will remove them right now and see
That is a good plan.
alright and i will ask lawyer here for more info about our rules
thanks alot :)
Let me know if you have any other questions. If you are satisfied with my answer place rate it!
i will for sure
Best of luck.
thank you for your time
I have asked some lawyers in my country and they said that i must first receive a diplomatic warning directly to me from their Embassy or any other way and the email doesn't count as a warning.
What do think about that? I have not received any warning or notice to me directly what i have received is only an email from the host provider in usa and they forwarded the email to the guy who designed my website not to me.
Thanks and sorry for my bad english
unfortunately lawyers here in kuwait don't know alot about intellectual property. and it is a very small country.
But they all said the same thing to me that the email doesn't count as an offical warning.
I just had to ask you to confirm this.
thanks alot for all your help i appreciate it .
DISCLAIMER: Answers from Experts on JustAnswer are not substitutes for the advice of an attorney. JustAnswer is a public forum and questions and responses are not private or confidential or protected by the attorney-client privilege. The Expert above is not your attorney, and the response above is not legal advice. You should not read this response to propose specific action or address specific circumstances, but only to give you a sense of general principles of law that might affect the situation you describe. Application of these general principles to particular circumstances must be done by a lawyer who has spoken with you in confidence, learned all relevant information, and explored various options. Before acting on these general principles, you should hire a lawyer licensed to practice law in the jurisdiction to which your question pertains.
The responses above are from individual Experts, not JustAnswer. The site and services are provided “as is”. To view the verified credential of an Expert, click on the “Verified” symbol in the Expert’s profile. This site is not for emergency questions which should be directed immediately by telephone or in-person to qualified professionals. Please carefully read the Terms of Service (last updated February 8, 2012).