Intellectual Property Law
Intellectual Property Law Questions? Ask a Lawyer
No, there was no help whatsoever in the writing of the music or lyrics--the arrangement was helped with another friend, whom I'll gladly share arrangement copyright, as I understand these are seperate.
As to your question about claim, I have begun to worry lately, as there seems to be a lot of dischord here. There are three of us who've created the concert: The artist, who has copyrighted her art, the historian--who along with me and another partner who has since left the project--wrote the narrative, and myself, who wrote the music. There has never been any discussion over rights to individual pieces (except that I know the artist has secured or is in process of securing her artwork), and it was never my intention to give up ownership of my work. These things just never came up. No contracts on anything anywhere, which has always bothered my husband, cause he thinks we are all dumb artists, with no business sense. Especially now, that I have offers for my music to be used by individuals with money and the same desire to make a difference in the world, and the historian doesn't want me or our show involved with these guys--because he considers them to be "competition" to his own side business of teaching seminars about the constitution. This is what our concert is about, and we are one of many out there educating others about our nation's heritage and the framing of our government. My husband is concerned that, should we decide to go our seperate ways, over differences like these, that I need to be clear that I take my compositions with me, just as the artist will keep her work, and the historian will keep his seminar going. Quite frankly, it's the music that drives the emotion and spirit of the show, and it appears that my two partners are trying to keep me from leaving, by saying that it's the music, narration and images together that acheive the best results, and music alone doesn't have the impact--thus I need to stay and work with them only--though I am actively trying to bring the whole show in on the deal I'me being offered. But as of now, these new guys are only interested in my music, and it's making the other guys mad. FYI, they use their stuff alone all the time, and I never complain, but am happy for them. I want the same benefit!
Thank you for your patience, my apologies on the delay.Now I am beginning to see the situation a bit more clearly. The sheet music is indeed yours if you created the tune and the arrangement without any other input. The individual you listed for arrangement is indeed entitled to partial credit, but the sheet music is wholly yours. What you all share copyright on is the full and finished work. There all parties contributed and all parties have a legal interest in the intellectual property. Moving forward with the sheet music solely should be sufficient.Now, having said that, I suggest that you move quickly. The atmosphere appears to be somewhat poisonous so the faster you obtain formal copyright (you are correct, you do obtain a natural copyright when you create something unique yourself), the faster you can retain and affirm your rights once the inevitable split takes place. Also, please consider agreeing with your husband (at least this once)--get things in writing so as to avoid this potential stress and emotional blackmail in the future.Please be well!
Sooooo Sorry Dimitry--
One more thing to clarify: So the concert itself, as performed, we three own together? But I still maintain ownersip of my music outside of this? They cannot keep me from performing my music where ever else I desire? I'm absolutely fine with them using the music and keeping the concert going--so long as I am a part of it, so I can control the quality--that is fine; it's what we all wanted. I just want the right to use my work other places.
Now how about the recording? I am producing it, have done everything, by myself, to get it recorded, and am putting up some of my own money, along with an outside investor. Do I have equal share or a percentage? The artist has a company that she claims will call the shots, and I'm concerned she may think she only ows me mechanical liscensing...I'm not really in this for money, it's about the message. But I do not want to give up complete control, and if I'm due more than the mechanical fee, I do want that, if it's fair.
Last info bit--I have never been paid for my service...none of us have, except that money from the shows go through these two people's hands, and I never know where it ends up...no accounting whatsoever. I don't want this to be the case with the album!
Sorry--this is a convoluted situation and I am entirely too trusting, but my gut is telling me to be concerned!
Than you for your follow-up. Please do not be sorry, I will be happy to clarify.
One more thing to clarify: So the concert itself, as performed, we three own together?
But I still maintain ownersip of my music outside of this?
Also correct. You own the rights to the individual contribution to the whole, and you own the whole in part with the other participants.
They cannot keep me from performing my music where ever else I desire?
So long as you record your rights and do not use any of their elements, they will be hard-pressed to stop you UNLESS they claim that the melody is owned jointly by the whole group, something that you are contesting.
I'm absolutely fine with them using the music and keeping the concert going--so long as I am a part of it, so I can control the quality--that is fine; it's what we all wanted. I just want the right to use my work other places.
That would be a problem. By giving them the right to use the music, you are implicitly potentially agreeing that this was not sole ownership but group ownership. It would be wiser to allow them to use the music so long as after your record your copyright, they sign a written license agreement with you under which you agree to allow them to use your music in certain limited capacity--as that will ensure that the rights are yours, and not jointly held.
Now how about the recording?
If they are not on the recording you, own it.
I am producing it, have done everything, by myself, to get it recorded, and am putting up some of my own money, along with an outside investor. Do I have equal share or a percentage?
WIthout anything in writing, all the parties to the recording own equal shares.
The artist has a company that she claims will call the shots, and I'm concerned she may think she only ows me mechanical liscensing...I'm not really in this for money, it's about the message. But I do not want to give up complete control, and if I'm due more than the mechanical fee, I do want that, if it's fair.
That is wise, and getting that put in writing is also very wise.
That is a bit separate of an issue and is really beyond the scope of your question as it does not deal with intellectual property. However if you have nothing in writing, it will be hard for you to demand disclosure or accounting to take place.
This situation, as far as you described it, does not appear to be positive, I agree, so please be careful.
DISCLAIMER: Answers from Experts on JustAnswer are not substitutes for the advice of an attorney. JustAnswer is a public forum and questions and responses are not private or confidential or protected by the attorney-client privilege. The Expert above is not your attorney, and the response above is not legal advice. You should not read this response to propose specific action or address specific circumstances, but only to give you a sense of general principles of law that might affect the situation you describe. Application of these general principles to particular circumstances must be done by a lawyer who has spoken with you in confidence, learned all relevant information, and explored various options. Before acting on these general principles, you should hire a lawyer licensed to practice law in the jurisdiction to which your question pertains.
The responses above are from individual Experts, not JustAnswer. The site and services are provided “as is”. To view the verified credential of an Expert, click on the “Verified” symbol in the Expert’s profile. This site is not for emergency questions which should be directed immediately by telephone or in-person to qualified professionals. Please carefully read the Terms of Service (last updated February 8, 2012).