How JustAnswer Works:
  • Ask an Expert
    Experts are full of valuable knowledge and are ready to help with any question. Credentials confirmed by a Fortune 500 verification firm.
  • Get a Professional Answer
    Via email, text message, or notification as you wait on our site.
    Ask follow up questions if you need to.
  • 100% Satisfaction Guarantee
    Rate the answer you receive.
Ask Expert James Your Own Question
Expert James
Expert James, Immigration Attorney
Category: Immigration Law
Satisfied Customers: 11715
Experience:  Write FOR JAMES to get my help!
Type Your Immigration Law Question Here...
Expert James is online now
A new question is answered every 9 seconds

I saw on the news a man crying about how the immigration refuses

Customer Question

I saw on the news a man crying about how the immigration refuses to accept his application that he was applying for his resident permanent they decline it because he was overweight that's the first time for me to hear that and I think that is not fair. for me they are racist they not treated everyone fairly some immigration officer they are just racism and I think its not suppose to be like that, they should kick their bud out of their job! what is your saying?
Submitted: 3 years ago.
Category: Immigration Law
Expert:  Expert James replied 3 years ago.

Thank you for using this service. I'll do my best to answer your questions as completely and honestly as I can. All I ask in return is that you give me a positive rating for my customer service. This is the only way I get credit for assisting you. If you feel the need to use "poor service" or "bad service," please ask follow-up questions instead, so that I can try to help you further. Please remember that the law sometimes does not have a satisfactory solution for your issue; unfortunately, this is something I cannot control.


What is my saying? I say that it is a terrible situation, and it sounds very unfair. I would be very upset. However it doesn't sound like it has anything to do with racism, but instead it has to do with how much of a healthcare and financial burden this person might be on the government.


Yes, it is a terrible situation. and it sounds very unfair. But unfortunately, the issue is one of the policy and procedures of the immigration service. Most countries make immigration decisions taking into consideration how much of a burden the applicant will be on the country. Most of the time, that takes into account something like how much of the health care system a person will require, and if they can afford to pay for it. In some countries where there is medical care for free or at a reduced price by the government, countries don't want to allow people to immigrate who they feel will be a take too much from the medical system or healthcare system, as it is expensive.


Each country has the right to do this. And remember that a person who is not a citizen of that country does not have the right to any immigration benefits.


If a country has a health care system that it feels will be burdened by an immigrant, the country has the right to deny immigration benefits. And as we now know, obesity (being too overweight) is the leading cause of many serious illnesses, which can be a burden on the health care system.


In this US, this is very common, where an alien is likely to become a "public charge," the US will not grant immigration benefits unless the person can show that either he or someone else is willing to take on the financial burden if the person become a public charge of the government.


It's not fair and may not even be right to do it, but unfortunately, each country has the right to make immigration determinations based on their own laws and considerations. And most countries take into consideration if the person is going to use free benefits because of their health conditions. So it isn't the immigration officer's fault, it's the laws and policies of the country that allow the officer to make this decision.


It is terrible and unfair, but it is the country's choice to do it that way.


I hope I have answered your questions. Keep in mind that I only get credit for my work if you rate me positively. If you're satisfied with my answer and my professionalism - not the outcome or the state of the law which I cannot control - please select a top-three rating. Again, if you feel the need to use "poor service" or "bad service," please ask follow-up questions instead, so that I can try to help you further. Remember that the bottom two negative ratings are used for Experts or professionals who are rude and/or bad at their job, and I'm confident you'll find me to be professional and truthful with you.

A bonus is appreciated, if you feel I've earned it.

If you want me to answer questions in the future, you can write "FOR LONGHORN" at the beginning of your question, or go directly to my question page here: Ask Longhorn Lawyer

Thank you!

Related Immigration Law Questions