My spouse is a legal resident of the US from the Philippines. She has been in the US since 2005. She applied for citizenship in 2008. On the application it asked if she had ever been in an incident with the police and she told them of an incident where she and a friend had found a bank debit card in a parking lot and she and her friend charged a few hundred dollars of merchandise on the card. Her conscience told her this was wrong and she told me about it that day when I got home from work. We notified the police ,found the owner of the card,returned the card and reimbursed the card owner for all the money charged . The owner declined to press charges and there was never even a police record of the incident(we checked to see).This was the only negative incident against my wife's record even to this day. She was denied citizenship on moral turpitude grounds because of mentioning the incident. We appealed and she was still denied.Her friend applied for citizenship the next year not mentioning the incident and was granted citizenship. I'm wondering if my wife should reapply or would this "black Mark" follow her the rest of her life. We have 2 children now and she would really like to get her citizenship some day. AS i SAID,SHE'S NEVER EVEN HAD SO MUCH AS A SPEEDING TICKET SINCE 2005.

Optional Information:
State/Country relating to question: Georgia

Already Tried:
WE APPEALED AS STATED IN THE PREVIOUS QUESTION.