Have a Finance Question? Ask a Financial Expert Online.
Hi, if you have bullion, then Section 408(m)(3)(B) states that it must be held “in the physical possession of a trustee”. Usually, that ends up being a specialized third-party custodian. For coins, however, the Code has no such requirements. In fact, the Code does not place any restrictions whatsoever of the storage of gold coins. That means that your retirement account can purchase gold coins and you can hold onto them personally.
I know of a company called Broad Financial (I have no affiliation) that will let you hold the and silver
Ok, that's great. But how do I get the coins from the company now holding them. Do I have to do some kind of rollover like I did when I took the money out of my traditional IRA and bought the coins
That's right, you do still need a trustee for the paperwork and tax reporting reporting...
Each trustee has a different procedure, but you'll do a rollover to the new IRS "account"
sorry for the typo (IRA) account
wait a minute... i need to look at something...
the the new trustee will direct the existing trtustee to send the physical pieces to you
The trustee will typically charge a one-time IRA set-up fee (perhaps $25 to $50), an annual management fee for producing account statements and handling other paperwork
Here's a good marketwatch story on the issue
Even THAT story implies that the storage must be done by the custodian... but here's waht Broad Financial says about it
"We have found that gold dealers are often misinformed in this area and erroneously inform their clients that gold coins may not be personally held. This could either be due to the fact that most people, including precious metals dealers, are not well versed in the Internal Revenue Code. Or it could just be that the dealers would rather hold your gold themselves so that they can charge holding fees. Whatever the case may be, the law is clear. Gold bullion must be held by an approved custodian, while gold coins may be held personally without restriction."
let me ask this: there are two fees charged by my current trustee : precious metal IRA fee and a storage fee. if I asked them to send me the gold then I would save the storage fee, but they could continue to be my trustee, does that sound right
That's right, as long as they will DO it ... there's no law that says they HAVE to, but as you can see from the Broad Financial Info, it IS possible if its not bullion
There just has to be a trustee ... you have ti
not bullion, coin. what does the law say? could they refuse to send me the coins?
Yes, that's an issue of there not being any law that says they HAVE to .. their business model is their choice
they cannot refuse a rollover request BUT and they cannot refuse to send you your gold
sorry ... BUT, thy could code it a distribution, you'd have to pay taxes and a 10% penalty if you dont get it back in somewhere within 60 days
OK, so I am paying a storage fee because no one said I had the choice to hold it myself, they simply provided a service and I didn't question it . does that sound right? What wording would you suggest I use to get my coins shipped to me
I would say the following:
Regarding account number xxxxxxxx, I would like to request that you send me the coins, so that I can store them myself. I would like for you to continue to be the trustee of the IRA.. please advise the method you prefer for shipping, pickup, etc.
Honestly, I'd start with a phone call
But you can always do it by mail (and maybe send certified, so you'll have proof that they received it?)
That sounds best. Then If they need it in writing I'll do that too. Ok, Lane thank you very much I feel better about the whole thing now just knowing I have choices.
yes, and remember that if they say the won't do it that way... you go to the new trustee and they can then have it rolled over to the new ira "account," bu have them sent to you for physical storage
Glad I could help
If this HAS helped, I would appreciate a feedback rating of 3 (OK) or better … That's the only way they will pay us here.
HOWEVER, if you need more on this, PLEASE COME BACK here, so you won't be charged for another question.
ok great advice. Thanks so much...