Employment Law Questions? Ask an Employment Lawyer.
Hi, thanks for submitting your question today. My name is John. I have over 13 years of legal and consulting experience in this area. I’m happy to assist you with your question today. Please note that the website may ask you if you desire premium services, such as a phone call. I do not control these prompts, and you are not under any obligation to order premium services to get a full answer from me. If you do desire premium services, however, feel free to select that option. I will have an answer for you shortly, unless I require additional information. Please be patient as I may have to research some matters before providing a response.
Legally you cannot keep a check to satisfy an unintentional overpayment unless you have a dispute procedure in place. NY DOL regulations state "For deductions due to overpayments or advances, employers must develop and follow a dispute procedure by which the employee may dispute the overpayment or terms of recovery, seek a delay in the recovery of such overpayment, or dispute the amount and frequency of deductions for advances that are not in accordance with the terms of an authorization for such advance. Failure to follow the procedures set forth in the Regulations will create a presumption that the deduction is impermissible."
Thus, legally unless you have such dispute procedure in place, such deduction would not be allowed. If you do not have such a procedure, then you'd have to pay the last paycheck, then pursue the employee in civil court for the overpayment. You could try to just attempt to hold the last paycheck and see what the employee does (threaten them with criminal prosecution), but if they file a charge with the DOL I'd suggest paying it immediately because you will lose there and may owe a penalty as well.
You can theoretically file a police report for the overpayment, in most instances the prosecutor will not file a charge in these instance because they don't believe hey can show it is a matter of criminal intent (versus a business dispute). In most instances even the police will try to dissuade you from filing a report because they'll state it's a criminal matter.
I believe this answers your question. However, if you need clarification or have follow-up questions regarding this matter, I will be happy to continue our conversation – simply reply to this answer. If you are otherwise satisfied with my response, please leave a positive rating as it is the only way I am able to get credit for my answers. Thank you, ***** ***** wish you all the best with this matter.
You're welcome. Please leave a positive rating before you exit this chat as it is the only way I get credit for my answers. If you have any questions in the future regarding this matter come back to this thread and I'll be happy to answer. Thanks and good luck with the matter.