Employment Lawyers Can Answer Your Employment Law Questions
I am a 56 y/o/f - Registered Nurse working for a large insurance company. My concern has to do with being wrongfully accused of 1) doing drugs and 2) lying to my supervisor. My supervisor councelled me about being accused by an anonymous co-worker of "doing drugs" and was going to report me to the ethics board. This accusation was based on a statement she said she overheard me make to another co-worker that I had a medication hangover that morning. This accusation remains in my "file" without documented resolution. This happened 1 year ago. I was not offered the opportunity to be drug tested or submit a written response. Did you know you can go get yourself drug tested? Speak to your own doctor and ask for such a Rx for a blood test. Don't rely on others to build your evidence for you, particularly if they have an agenda that is inconsistent with your interests.
At the time I was devastated by this that I did not request either of the above to clear my name. I understand.
Then 2 weeks ago I was given permission to work from home (via computer linked thru my computer at work) in order to be available for workers to come to my house to switch from one cable provider to another. OK.
I was working on the computer when the technician disconnected me without warning from the internet. OK, yes, that will happen if they are there to change your provider.
I immediately notified my supervisor by phone of the situation. Good. And I immediately notified her by IM as soon as I was told I had access to the internet again which was approx 2 hours later.
I have now been accused by my boss and her boss of lying about about not being able to work for those 2+ hours. But you didn't lie, right? You admitted you couldn't work those hours because the cable co. disconnected the internet access, correct? Consider printing off your phone detail record showing your outgoing call to the office at the very time it occurred. And if you DID document your IM print a copy. If you didn't think to take a screen shot or the like and it is not saved in an account on your computer, try to remember in the future.
There is much more in my "file" that she is keeping on me. Well, that is the job.
The majority of these "notes" are unfounded and unwarranted. Who decided unfounded? Were they investigated? Or or you just saying your opinion?
For instance, I called her to tell her I did not like how one of our doctors talked to me -"Do it Mary! Just do it!" - in regards XXXXX XXXXX him information on a case. OK. Not seeing anything illegal there.
But her note is only about the doctor telling her that my documentation is 'lacking'. OK, I know we don't like it when a co-worker speaks to us without the respect and/or professionalism we would like. However, unless you have a written contract where the employer has bound itself to document your complaints on decorum or illspeaking co-workers, the employer CAN pick and choose how to run its business and deal with complaints. I.e. as of now, no state, including LA, requires that an employer even address complaints of rudeness between employees, much less put it in writing. It is also free to treat complaining employees differently, based on the employee, based on the type of complaint, etc. But it can NOT treat them differently based on a protected discriminatory class, such as, "she is female and he is male." As such, we won't worry about her complaints, but we will document his. (Or Race, disability, nationality, etc.).
My supervisor and I were peers and friends at work prior to her promotion. She told me after the work at home incidence that she has "trust" issues with me which she has shared with her supervisor (which was also a peer prior to promotion) and is now under the impression that I am untrustworthy. That is untrustworthy. If she is legitimately concerned (as in, "really" is unsure, rather than knowoing you are legit but trying to make you appear illegit to others), consider showing her the proof that what you say happened, actually happened. In fact, you probably DO have the work receipt from the tech that was at your house. Use it.
I have never been accused of such things, am innocent of these accusations What accusations??? You mean this one about not working those 2 hours that you intended to work, but couldn't due to internet? Show her the proof of what happened and offer to make up the hours.
and need guidance what steps I should take to have all of this resolved. It will only be resolved if both parties want it to. If an employer (or its agent) does not choose to resolve favorably, and there is no contract term that you were able to secure in writing that forces the employer to favorably resolve, or give you some level of "due process" before disciplining, you can only rely on it choosing to do so in its discretion, because you have no contract where it is obligated to do so. That being the case, what is often the best (but never guaranteed tactic) is to bend over backwards to get them to either look at your evidence and realize you are telling the truth, and/or realize how sincere you are in wanting to continue to do the best job possible, and put this behind you both. But THEY have the power and you do not - i.e. neither side can force the other to do anything in particular. Each side can decide to terminate the employment relationship.
My supervisor still has doubts of my truthfulness even after providing her with a letter from the cable provider supporting me. OK, that is helpful. Now show her your phone detail that proves you called her at X'O'clock as soon as connection went down.
Any guidance you might have for me in this troubling situation would be greatly appreciated. Hope this helps Mary. It sounds like you do need to schmooze, but getting evidence is likely the best way to prove to her factually that you did indeed call as soon as power went out. Offering to make up the work, and perhaps a little extra to show you are trying to make whatever is lacking due to your not working, be fixed so there is no loss to the company from your loss of 2 hours of work at that time. That would likely be the stance I would take.
Thank you! Mary
Optional Information: Country relating to Question: United StatesState (if USA): LouisianaWhat have you tried so far?: My supervisor and I met to discuss her reasoning for not trusting me. To add to my concern in my narrative - I was told that I could not work from home for 3 months (which is not a problem for me) and that I would have to take a full day Personal Time Off if I had to go to any appointments (I am currently being treated for hypertension and depression by two different physicians.) Is it legal for them to make me use 8 hours of my PTO for a 1 hour doctor appointment - after which I almost always return to work to finish out the day? Possibly, if it is a legitimate need. But, also look at possible FMLA protection. While we can get intermittent FMLA time off at times, there are rules that say an employer can't charge you 8 hours off your 12 weeks of FMLA leave (unpaid possibly) if you only need 2. Alternatively, if you don't want to make more waves, consider making your appointments at night or on weekends. Many doctors have evening appts. available, or weekends, so consider using such a doctor so you are not asking for more concession, when you are already in the hotseat. I.e. make your personal medical needs your issue and not your employer's inconvenience, to help you get back into the position of trust you seek.
I hope this helps! My goal is to provide you with excellent and accurate service – if you feel you have gotten anything less, please reply back, I am happy to address follow-up questions. Kindly rate me "excellent" when you are done. I look forward to assisting you in the future, should you have legal questions.
Thank you for your response. Although I am not particularly happy with it - I do appreciate your time and expertise. The 2 hrs offline - I continued to work - making calls and doing handwritten tasks. The documented phone calls, a letter from the cable company, documentation from our own IT department - and a copy of the IM where she 'inferred' that I lied about those 2 hours. Also, I am an exempt employee - I work overtime VERY often without issue and on this particular day 1 of the 2 hours was my lunch break and I did work past 5pm to complete the work i was doing at the time I lost internet connection.
In my opinion, she is refusing to accept that she was in the wrong - especially about those 2 hours. My concern is, with her new position comes power and she doesn't know how to handle it . My job is extremely important to me - as is my integrity as a professional and a person. To be labeled as a drug user and a liar is the death of my reputation. Now, because knowing what my supervisor (and former friend) thinks of me, my sense of security in my job has been threatened. When it was told to me that I was reported for "using drugs" I did bend over backward to prove myself but apparently that didn't work. And with this current accusation of lying (and yes I believe accused is accurate) bending over backward to placate would only be seen as an admission of quilt.
I truly aim to please you as a customer, but please keep in mind that I do not know what you already know or don't know, or with what you need help, unless you tell me. Please consider that I am answering the question or question that is posed in your posting based upon my reading of your post and sometimes misunderstandings can occur. If I did not answer the question you thought you were asking, please respond with the specific question you wanted answered.
Kindly remember the ONLY WAY experts receive any credit at all for spending time with customers is if you click on OK, GOOD or EXCELLENT SERVICE even though you have made a deposit or are a subscription customer. YOU MUST COMPLETE THE RATING FOR THE EXPERT TO RECEIVE ANY CREDIT, if not the site keeps your money on deposit.
Also remember, sometimes the law does not support what we want it to support, but that is not the fault of the person answering the question, so please be courteous.
Thank you very much for responding to my quandary. It's sad to think that being loyal to the company you work for, and the supervisor who is there to guide you, means nothing. I was hoping to find some words of encouragement that would, in some way, make me feel like I had some rights in my workplace and security in my job/career. Anyway, I thank you again for your attention to my concerns.
Thank you for your response. Although I am not particularly happy with it And that I very much understand.
- I do appreciate your time and expertise. The 2 hrs offline - I continued to work - making calls and doing handwritten tasks. The documented phone calls, a letter from the cable company, documentation from our own IT department - and a copy of the IM where she 'inferred' that I lied about those 2 hours. I know that is upsetting, her lack of trust.
Also, I am an exempt employee - I work overtime VERY often without issue Ugh! I understand, having been exempt for the past 20 or so years myself. And it makes her nitpicky lack of trust even more troublesome, since you clearly have MORE than made up for 2 hours, regardless, well before this event.
and on this particular day 1 of the 2 hours was my lunch break and I did work past 5pm to complete the work i was doing at the time I lost internet connection. It does sound like she has some other things going on in her mind. An agenda perhaps or a bit of a mental disorder or hang up of some kind, since she can't seem to piece those facts together, to realize that clearly nothing was amiss, with regard to your work productivity and devotion to it.
In my opinion, she is refusing to accept that she was in the wrong - especially about those 2 hours. Sounds accurate.
My concern is, with her new position comes power and she doesn't know how to handle it . My job is extremely important to me - as is my integrity as a professional and a person. To be labeled as a drug user and a liar is the death of my reputation. Absolutely. If she is spreading such false statements, you have a lot to consider, as to how you choose to deal with that.
Now, because knowing what my supervisor (and former friend) thinks of me, my sense of security in my job has been threatened. It truly never really is secure, short of a good strong employment contract making it so - and it is far more fragile a security when one is dealing, as you are, with a troubled superior or anyone, really, who is less than concerned with your job security.
When it was told to me that I was reported for "using drugs" I did bend over backward to prove myself but apparently that didn't work. It is appalling - I'd be quite livid.
And with this current accusation of lying (and yes I believe accused is accurate I agree - lying is definitely a negative, so accusation does seem an appropriate term) bending over backward to placate would only be seen as an admission of quilt.Possibly. Although there are no guarantees, of course, that NOT placating would reverse the situation.
I realize you cherish your job and how important it is to you. Being the type of person to be cautious and one who seeks to always "plan for the worst while hoping for the best" - do you think that you job is substantially at risk enough, even if only possibly and prospectively, that it may be idea to get your networking hat on and see what it out there that could be as good or better than this job? ... So you have options should the "worst" occur or even if the worst doesn't occur, but you find yourself not enjoying your current job so much that you actually want to leave it, and move on. Surprisingly, it does seem that often times, when a workplace turns sour, and one has the opportunity to job seek while she still has a job, the opportunities out there can be very appealing, and within reach. 6 months or a year from now, you could be saying to yourself, "Thank goodness for that 'bad' situation last year - had it not occurred, I'd likely never have looked to see what else is out there, and never would have gotten my current wonderful position." I do hope you situation improves where you are at, but if it doesn't, not all is lost - just a different fork in the road.
I hope this helps!
DISCLAIMER: Answers from Experts on JustAnswer are not substitutes for the advice of an attorney. JustAnswer is a public forum and questions and responses are not private or confidential or protected by the attorney-client privilege. The Expert above is not your attorney, and the response above is not legal advice. You should not read this response to propose specific action or address specific circumstances, but only to give you a sense of general principles of law that might affect the situation you describe. Application of these general principles to particular circumstances must be done by a lawyer who has spoken with you in confidence, learned all relevant information, and explored various options. Before acting on these general principles, you should hire a lawyer licensed to practice law in the jurisdiction to which your question pertains.
The responses above are from individual Experts, not JustAnswer. The site and services are provided “as is”. To view the verified credential of an Expert, click on the “Verified” symbol in the Expert’s profile. This site is not for emergency questions which should be directed immediately by telephone or in-person to qualified professionals. Please carefully read the Terms of Service (last updated February 8, 2012).