Criminal Law Questions? Ask a Criminal Lawyer.
PA and MD
I was seeing my primary doctor and already on medication for two buldged disks in my lower back then he i was in an accident and have two buldged disks in my neck which I was also recieving medication for this issue as when I asked my primary doctor to see me the day I had my accident he refused to take auto claims in which the one doctor is on my auto insurrance and my primary on my medical in which I was already recieving medication. they are saying i am not allowed to receive medication for both as I did not speak to my primary doctor about my pain doctor on auto claim as he said they do not do auto claims. So i thought i was to keep them seperate and did not disclose to either about my issue. I thought i was doing the right thing as i had a different claim number for the accident doctor and health on my medical. am I going to jail and loose my job and be arressted. how will i know if there is a warrant for my arrest i am very confused.
They are saying since I got narcotics from both doctors for the past year that the letter said narcotic seeking i have been on both medications for a year and was ready to have neck surgery until they found cancer in my thyroid and my surgery date is for this week and I am worried they are going to come and arrest me at my job or at my house. Will they put out a warrant for my arrest. I did not know i was doing anything wrong i thought i had confidentiality not telling the doctor about the other since they are from differnt sources: lower back injury from 15 years ago which is what my primary doctor was seeing me for then my car accident that injured my neck and two buldged disks as the MRI shows and again have to have surgery. I no longer have a doctor and on one will probably take me now. what do i do about finding another doctor do i go to a pain type of clinic they stopped my medication and I have depression and was doing better as i was able to do more things without pain. is this confidential?
Sorry to keep bothering you. But i did a research online and i saw these doctor shopping laws. I was taking both medications from each doctor for year and it came up as doctor shopping. Will this information come up on my background check I get for my job every couple of years? Just trying to understand what to expect. I have no primary doctor or any doctors anymore should i tell the new doctor when i find one about this?
You have been great in helping me understand the issue at hand. If they decide to investigate how long will this take? Should i expect someone to contact me from the law months from now? How do I move forward with finding a doctor for my neck issue in which I am to have surgery just see the surgeon and move forward?
So based on your expertise and knowledge i will not be charged (especially since my primary doctor was in MD and my pain doctor for my accident was in PA).?
Hello, I just have one more question. Will the certified letter from both doctors in which one states them discharging me be placed in my medical record/s and be pulled whenever I sign any HIPPA agreements?
*When done reviewing my answer, please press a rating button BELOW THIS ANSWER BOX in order to rate my answer and pay me for my time.
I am a different expert at Just Answer -- my colleague has stepped away and asked me to pick up this question for him because I have considerable experience in this area.
First, I want you to take a deep breath and RELAX. It seems that you are very stressed out and upset over this situation and being under that stress does not help your medical situation and your pain level in any shape, manner or form. You are not going to be charged with a crime in this situation -- I can virtually guarantee it. WHat happened here was an unfortunate mistake on your part and you were not given the chance by the doctors involved to explain what happened and why it happened. Doctor shopping is a different thing entirely than what happened here to you -- doctor shopping is a criminal matter only when it gets to the point where a patient visits a bunch of different doctors at the same time or at almost the same time in order to just get pain medication. Typically, these cases are charged when the patient gets up to about 6 or 7 doctors at the same time or in a very short period of time from each other and all of the doctors write out pain medication for the patient. Your situation does not rise to that level at all -- and your doctors are not going to involve the police and take time out of their own practices in order to go to court against you -- it simply will not and would not happen in a case such as yours that you described above (it is up to the doctors whether or not to prosecute and send the matter to the local police and if they had done that you would have heard from the police by now).
My own husband has been in this unfortunate situation several times over the last 20 years. He had 2 back surgeries, 2 hand surgeries and he continues to work in construction where he suffers 6 or 7 accidents every year that land him in the emergency room. My husband has been dropped by 3 doctors in 20 years because there are some doctors who would rather just dump a patient than determine what is really wrong with the patient and work with the patient to alleviate their pain -- and each time he has been dropped he received certified letters and then simply found another doctor. In each case, the doctor dropped my husband because they claimed he visited the emergency room too much -- even though the injuries have all been legitimate because of being in the construction business (for example, he has had a concussion, fallen from a ladder and had a shard of metal land in his eye in the last 8 months alone). Unfortunately, it is the doctors right to drop a patient when the doctor does not want to have to deal with the DEA regarding writing out any prescription pain medication and most doctors I have dealt with will drop a patient in a moment rather than speak with the DEA and explain to the DEA why the patient has had so many injuries and why the patent must have pain medications prescribed. It really is sad to say it, but we are living in a day and age when a person suffering from debilitating pain cannot get adequate pain relief because the doctors are all afraid of the DEA and so long as doctors have the right to drop a patient for any reason or no reason, we will see more and more of this happening every day.
So, as my colleague said, doctor shopping is not a crime in the states you mentioned. However, what you did does not even rise to the level of doctor shopping -- you simply violated the internal policy of the doctor's offices that they will dump any patient who receives a pain prescription from more than one doctor at the same time -- without even giving the doctor the chance to explain. The certified letters will not appear in your medical records (or show up regarding any future HIPPA agreements), and the last entries of these two doctors will most likely either not explain why you no longer see the doctor or will simply state that the relationship was terminated without stating who terminated the relationship. You should start looking for another doctor and my suggestion is that you find one doctor to treat you for everything and simply tell the doctor that you did not have a good fit with the prior doctor if any questions are asked -- and then you should not bring anything up with the new doctor unless you are asked any direct questions about the prior situation and what happened to end the relationship. In my husband's case, he was never asked any questions and when he provided proof of the prior doctors treatment and prescriptions then the new doctor pretty much followed the same treatment.
Please let me know if you have more questions. If not, can you please press the 3rd, 4th or 5th smile face underneath THIS ANSWER BOX (BELOW) so I will be paid for my time. I am paid nothing unless you press a positive rating BELOW -- pressing a positive rating will NOT cost you any additional money -- it simply acts as a trigger to Just Answer to pay me for my time.
DISCLAIMER: Answers from Experts on JustAnswer are not substitutes for the advice of an attorney. JustAnswer is a public forum and questions and responses are not private or confidential or protected by the attorney-client privilege. The Expert above is not your attorney, and the response above is not legal advice. You should not read this response to propose specific action or address specific circumstances, but only to give you a sense of general principles of law that might affect the situation you describe. Application of these general principles to particular circumstances must be done by a lawyer who has spoken with you in confidence, learned all relevant information, and explored various options. Before acting on these general principles, you should hire a lawyer licensed to practice law in the jurisdiction to which your question pertains.
The responses above are from individual Experts, not JustAnswer. The site and services are provided “as is”. To view the verified credential of an Expert, click on the “Verified” symbol in the Expert’s profile. This site is not for emergency questions which should be directed immediately by telephone or in-person to qualified professionals. Please carefully read the Terms of Service (last updated February 8, 2012).