Recent Feedback
High Level:IN July 2012, I was arrested and charged with: 1) Misdemeanor Assault - Class 1 2) Disorderly Conduct - Disturbance - Class 1During the initial court date, I was offered a plea agreement, where the assault charge would be dropped, if I plead guilty to the disorderly conduct charge. I did not accept/decline the offer, but requested, and received, a motion to continue.My intent, was to use this time to obtain an attorney. Through procrastination, available funds, and a busy work schedule, I have not obtained said attorney. My second court date is tomorrow, and I need to determine the best course of action.My options (as I see them):A) Accept the pleaB) Plead not guiltyC) Request a second continuanceIdeally, I would like to receive a second continuance, which will allow me to obtain legal representation.Item 1What I am looking to understand, is the likelihood that the prosecutor will/will-not grant me a second extension. In general, is granting of such a request 'rare'?Item 2If the prosecutor does not grant the extension, do I have any options to achieve a similar goal (delay so I have time to obtain an attorney).Item 3If I do not receive a continuance, and no other options exist to provide the time I need to obtain an attorney, I need to determine the course of action with the least amount of (potential) risk. If I were to plead not-guilty, how aggressive do prosecutors generally pursue such cases? In my instance, I have no criminal background (not a repeat offender, etc). To a certain extent, pleading not guilty would provide me the time needed to obtain an attorney, but I'm concerned at that point I may have set myself up for failure as I have already delivered my plea. I understand you can't determine how aggressive my particular prosecutor will pursue, but in general, how much effort is placed to obtain a guilty verdict (witnesses, evidence, etc) for a misdemeanor assault charge?Background on incident (if it may impact the above options)After work on a Friday I went by myself to a bar to listen to a particular band. While there, I met a few guys and we were talking outside the door (in process of leaving). While we were talking there was an unrelated scuffle nearby. After, someone approached me and started yelling at me to leave (not an employee). I had no idea who he was or why he was approaching me. He started to approach me faster, I became worried and pushed the individual away. He fell, injured his head and when the police arrived, I was arrested.
Optional Information: Country relating to Question: United StatesState (if USA): ArizonaWhat have you tried so far?: I have provided this information within main question.
Hello,.Item 1What I am looking to understand, is the likelihood that the prosecutor will/will-not grant me a second extension. In general, is granting of such a request 'rare'?.Typically a continuance is granted the first time without any real reason necessary. A second continuance is a little harder to get, but is usually granted if the defendant explains that they have approached several attorneys and are close to having the money to hire one. As a former public defender, it wasn't really that uncommon for several continuances to be granted in low level cases. So no, it isn't particularly rare for a prosecutor to agree to a second continuance..Item 2If the prosecutor does not grant the extension, do I have any options to achieve a similar goal (delay so I have time to obtain an attorney)..Yes, you simply plead not guilty and request a trial date which is typically several months off..Item 3If I do not receive a continuance, and no other options exist to provide the time I need to obtain an attorney, I need to determine the course of action with the least amount of (potential) risk. If I were to plead not-guilty, how aggressive do prosecutors generally pursue such cases? .They don't aggressively pursue cases like this. They aren't going to get mad if you plead not guilty. These type of cases are more of an inconvenience to the prosecutor as they could conceivably take up a half day of their time if it actually went to trial and they much prefer to settle them rather than have to go through the time and effort to prepare for a trial like this.In my instance, I have no criminal background (not a repeat offender, etc). To a certain extent, pleading not guilty would provide me the time needed to obtain an attorney, but I'm concerned at that point I may have set myself up for failure as I have already delivered my plea. I understand you can't determine how aggressive my particular prosecutor will pursue, but in general, how much effort is placed to obtain a guilty verdict (witnesses, evidence, etc) for a Misdemeanor assault charge?.In a case like this, if it is set for trial, it will typically be a few months out. The prosecutor won't even start doing anything in preparation for the trial until about 3 weeks away other than contacting any witnesses to make sure he can get in contact with them about a week before trial. .Further, you can always change your plea at any time if you change your mind and the original offer will still be there. Actually, in my experience of handling literally hundreds of cases like this, the offer gets better the closer to trial because prosecutors hate to try a case like this with questionable facts as it means other cases have to get backed up while they work on this one..So worst case scenario, you plead not guilty, get a trial date a few months off, get an attorney, and then change your plea if he doesn't feel you have a good case and accept the disorderly offer..
.
Thanks.
Barrister
Please remember to rate my answer. I will gladly continue our discussion until you have gotten the information you need.
If you need further help, just reply to me via the “REPLY” or “CONTINUE CONVERSATION” button.
Please keep in mind that I am trying to help you understand and resolve your situation. I don't make the laws, I am just reporting or interpreting them, so the outcome may not be what you had hoped for.
. Please be patient as I am typically working with several customers at any given time. Some answers take 5 minutes, some 35 minutes. But rest assured, I will get back to you.
I am not entering into an attorney client relationship, this is a public forum, and all posts are available for public viewing. There is no duty of confidentiality that attaches to any posts. With that in mind, do not post any specific information you do not want available for public viewing. The information provided is not a substitute for a local attorney’s legal advice.
Experience: 12 years practicing criminal defense.