Consumer Protection Law
Consumer Protection Law Questions? Ask a Lawyer Now.
Can I go and file an eviction notice with the court tomorrow and have it not be a wrongful eviction? (reverse it) I called the magistrate court and asked them if I could give the tenant an eviction notice without going to court and evict them without going to court and they told me yes. They told me I did not have to go to court to evict a person if they were willing to leave on their own. Was this person wrong and mislead me? I have a clause in my lease that landlord has the right to come into a unit without notice in an emergent situation (IE: water leak, gas leak, smell smoke, etc) and address the problem. There was a water leak so I did have the right to shut off the water so it could be fixed. As far as the electric.....such a sad situation.....are you saying that many peoples homes and lives can be destroyed due to a bunch of marajuna smoking junkies who have played the gas companies and stole from them? they are the criminals.....why do they not go to jail>?...so what is the next step and what are the consequences? There is an issue of electric that is not moderately not safe. I had an electrician scheduled to come. it was ok if you did not use the outlet and I had a plate over the outlet so it could not use it and they removed the plate. Do I have any fight in that arena to shut if off? I feel I had the right to shut the water off due to the leak? am I right? it had to be shut off to fix it. The water company had no problem shutting it off and did not tell me it was illegal. Are they wrong? Should they have told me or was it illegal to shut it off to fix it?
With respect to eviction, a tenant can voluntarily leave; you cannot force them out. In other words the the typical eviction notice states if you leave on your own no legal action will be taken. You can ask the tenants to leave, I believe this was the message they were trying to convey. Here is a link to a brochure on the eviction process in WV
You have the right to shut off the water to fix it, but not just shut off the water because there is a leak which will not be repaired in a timely manner. No one wants wasted water. A repair for a water leak should be done within a day or 2 that is justifiable. Intentionally delaying the repair is called a constructive eviction, the failure to repair. If you called to have repairs made immediately upon discovering the leak then you do not have a problem with the water being off even if the repairs take a long time e.g. running an entire water line.
If the water company shuts off the water because you failed to have a repair made then you have a problem. It is your responsibility to make sure that water is available to the tenants. Without water a unit is referred to as uninhabitable. Short periods without water are OK lengthy period due to the landlord not taking action is unacceptable.
With respect to the electrical heat you can specify that space heaters are not allowed, and you can file for eviction if the tenants violate that rule. The issue is not that the tenants should be evicted it is how you went about it. You needed to obtain a court order to force them out. You cannot illegally force them out of the property and then claim as justification they violated the lease.
With respect to the electrical outlet that is the landlord's responsibility to fix in a timely manner. Again a reasonable repair time is expected in a couple days, not weeks. If one outlet is bad or is questionable that yo cannot shut off the main breaker. You should t shut off the breaker for that outlet.
At this point you are on the hook to immediately fix the water and electrical and restore utility service. If not you tenants can make file a costly law suit against you. Initiate the appropriate eviction process. You need to be concerned that you stick to violations of lease terms, and failure to pay rent. Other actions could subject you to "retaliation claims" for complaining abut a wrongful eviction.
One last question.....I set up contractors and tell the tenant they are coming next week or in a couple of days and they stop the contractors from coming and then use that as a reason to not pay rent. They are players.....can I fight with this to protect myself? Also, they are doing damages to the property to keep from paying rent and are refusing to move their furniture so I can do some of the repairs (costly furniture that I would not even think of moving). I asked them to move it and they will not so I can not fix a loose wall paper. Can I fight with that?
Normally you have to give tenants adequate notice for when the contractors arrive. adequate notice is 24 hours or more. As long as you have given them that much notice you are entitled to enter. HOWEVER, you may not use violence or force to cause entry into the apartment. They cannot use that as a reason to not pay rent, and if they do not pay rent you should begin the eviction process immediately.
With respect to moving the furniture, if they will not move it and you are afraid to move it then the loose wallpaper stays. They cannot use that as a reason for not paying rent.
You need to take notes of all these items, and take photos including pictures of the contractors turned away. In "one party states" you can make an audio recording of what the tenants are saying to prevent access.
If I restore everything and my pipes do freeze and burst before she can be evicted can I sue her for her part in not having the gas turned on, especially since she has known since last April when the gas was turned off due to non payment and how do I go about it? or does she have the right to sue me for wrongful eviction if the pipes do freeze and burst? and if the house does burn down due to space heaters and I loose the $100,000 equity I have in the house can I sue her for that?....you can't get blood from a turnip....
if your tenants negligence is responsible for damage to your property you can sue for damages. You should write a letter to the tenant explaining that if the heat is not on pipes could burst and they will be liable for the damages.
You might also consider other preventative measure such as insulating the pipes just in case. While you can sue a tenant if they have no money your out of luck.
I still feel somehow foggy about all this......you said a tenant can countersue me? for what and what would be the max amount they could ask for? it seems almost crazy that a tenant who is manipulating a landlord and causing all the trouble on purpose could have any reason to sue me? what do you mean she could sue me?
Thank you so much !!! You have cleared up everything !!! They are in arrearages of $550.00 and if I file for an eviction before the 27th they can not sue me? am I right? Are you saying also that since they are not paying rent that I can fight that I have not fixed something because they did not pay rent?....even though I have fixed the pertinent things and the only things undone are the wallpaper and the electrical outlet due to them not moving their stuff....the water was just found on Friday....two days ago.....am I getting it right? is there anything I am misunderstanding? now there seems to be some justice in all of this....
If you get the utilities restored, file for eviction, wait for the court order granting your eviction, and the bailiff or sheriff throws them out they cannot sue you. Since they owe you rent you are not obligated to make repairs and they cannot sue you for not making the repairs.
The last page of the link I gave above has a summary of the process.
DISCLAIMER: Answers from Experts on JustAnswer are not substitutes for the advice of an attorney. JustAnswer is a public forum and questions and responses are not private or confidential or protected by the attorney-client privilege. The Expert above is not your attorney, and the response above is not legal advice. You should not read this response to propose specific action or address specific circumstances, but only to give you a sense of general principles of law that might affect the situation you describe. Application of these general principles to particular circumstances must be done by a lawyer who has spoken with you in confidence, learned all relevant information, and explored various options. Before acting on these general principles, you should hire a lawyer licensed to practice law in the jurisdiction to which your question pertains.
The responses above are from individual Experts, not JustAnswer. The site and services are provided “as is”. To view the verified credential of an Expert, click on the “Verified” symbol in the Expert’s profile. This site is not for emergency questions which should be directed immediately by telephone or in-person to qualified professionals. Please carefully read the Terms of Service (last updated February 8, 2012).