Hi, and Welcome to JustAnswer My name isXXXXX am a licensed, practicing Attorney and would like to help
The merchant engaged in deceptive business practices because there is no way for a customer to know the merchant's policy until after he has purchased the ring and received the invoice. Your recourse is to sue the merchant in Small Claims Court and tell the Judge that you
could not possibly have made an informed decision to buy the ring, if the merchant's policy was not clearly stated elsewhere, i.e., other
than on the invoice that a customer receives after the purchase.
the ring was bought in the bahamas...they have a office in new york...the policy was in small print on the back of the receipt/invoice....
You do not need a lawyer to sue in Small Claims Court, and if the merchant is a corporation (with "Inc," after its name) it must hire a lawyer
That is exactly what I am saying, How can you possibly have known the store's policy if you learned of it only after the purchase
what court would have jurisdiction
The fact that he operates a store in New York, means that you would have to sue him in New York because in suing a Defendant, the
Plaintiff must file suit in the County in which the Defendant can be served or where the cause of action arose. You certainly do not
want to sue in the Bahamas because you would never get justice there. Whereas, in New York your chance of winning is 1,000% greater than the Bahamas
as far as the bank, i had withdrew the money on a hunch that the resolution would not be satisfactory, hoping the bank would not let the purchase go through if the money wasnt there. they let it go through....can i be in trouble because i w/d the funds awaiting for the claim to be processed.
The Court which would have jurisdiction would be the Small Claims Court in the County where the Defendant operated his New York branch
Well, technically it would be the same as putting a "Stop Payment" on a check which was used to pay for merchandise. But, here, there's no harm done to the merchant, since he received his money anyway from your bank which left you with a negative balance,
Please be kind enough to rate "Excellent Service" so that I receive credit
for assisting you,
Bonus and Positive Feedback on survey is very much appreciated,
Thank you for allowing me the opportunity to be of assistance,
Do you need clarification on anything ?
Hi, are you still there ?
what options do i have in repaying the bank for the transaction that i thought they had on hold pending investigation. they said that since i signed the invoice and the signature line had a clause that said by signing i agree to the terms.,,,.i didnt know terms were on back. what they told me i was getting is not what i got according to the appraisal..but i didnt know of the policy on back that said the grade difference had to be off by 2 grades in order to have a legitimate return.
I do not understand what you mean "..what options do I have in repaying the bank.......... ?"
can the bank file charges against me for removing the funds....i will pay them back but only after a judgement
do i have to give them the money all at once
or can i pay gradually, i am unemployed...will they sue me for the full amount right away...did i break the law...
Normally, the bank would demand the money all at once because they paid it out. How did you originally pay for the ring ? By using your checking account ? If not how did you pay ?You said that you withdrew the money from the bank so that they would not pay the merchant. How much did you withdraw ?
Why did the bank go ahead and pay the merchant ? What type of account was it ?
The bank is not going to wait for you to sue the merchant and get a judgment against the merchant. Your best bet is not to even mention that. But, you should speak to the bank and tell them that you will pay them, but you do not have the means to pay it all at once. Be prepared with a good answer when the bank asks you why you bought the ring if you could not afford to and you are unemployed
the amount of 3999 which was appraised at 2500. from my debit card checking accout. they said they went ahead and paid it cause the merchant said i did not accept their resolution of 500 or 800 store credit. one customer serv rep. said he would submit a request of a 959 reduction. but another said no...i dont understand why the bank would pay them if the money was not there....
very high pressure sales technicque.....ie....cheapest place in the world to buy diamonds in the bahamas...saving thousands of dollars on this ring....come into the back and use our computer to transfer the funds into your cking acct...ect.
How much did you withdraw from your debit account ?
3999 the cost of the ring from my savings
left 100. balance
1500 from my checking...left 100
now balance in neg. 3999
Is it safe to assume that your debit card is linked to your savings or checking account ?
i am waiting for a call from the bank manager...i discovered this this am
What did you tell them at the bank ?
but they took money from both
i protested...up the ranks....waiting for head manager to come in at 2 est
The debit card is not linked to either of your 2 accounts ?
i was very upset that they paid without consulting me of the status of my claim....it is not linked
Do you just make deposits directly into your debit card account ?
debit is linked to checking acct
debit and checkiing is the same...
Do you have any arrangement with the bank to cover overdrafts ?
If you had no agreement with the bank, like in situations where a depositor has "overdraft" protection, they should not have paid anything to the merchant. In that case, the bank was totally wrong in paying this money to the merchant
thank you.........what do u think i should now do...can i demand that the bank assume the cost
I think in this situation, your best defense is an offense. You should be protesting to the bank's payment. They did not have the right to pay out the money and did not have the authority to make such payment. By doing so, they removed any leverage you had with the merchant, and this is something you should tell the bank manager.
DISCLAIMER: Answers from Experts on JustAnswer are not substitutes for the advice of an attorney. JustAnswer is a public forum and questions and responses are not private or confidential or protected by the attorney-client privilege. The Expert above is not your attorney, and the response above is not legal advice. You should not read this response to propose specific action or address specific circumstances, but only to give you a sense of general principles of law that might affect the situation you describe. Application of these general principles to particular circumstances must be done by a lawyer who has spoken with you in confidence, learned all relevant information, and explored various options. Before acting on these general principles, you should hire a lawyer licensed to practice law in the jurisdiction to which your question pertains.
The responses above are from individual Experts, not JustAnswer. The site and services are provided “as is”. To view the verified credential of an Expert, click on the “Verified” symbol in the Expert’s profile. This site is not for emergency questions which should be directed immediately by telephone or in-person to qualified professionals. Please carefully read the Terms of Service (last updated February 8, 2012).