Welcome, I am Cory.
How long has it been since you accessed the accounts?
If it has been 18 years, then I know for sure that the accounts have been deactivated without activity for more than 1 year. Because they have been activated, it means everything has been deleted. If you can activate them again, the account will open as a new one that you just started.
I do not see any reset options on AOL password ***** as this means you will have to contact AOL. You can contact AOL at 1-***-***-**** and maybe they can help you access them.
I am sorry, but I wish I had better news.
Please do not forget to look for the stars at the top of my page to rate my answer for informing you about your issue today.
Please let me know if you need further assistance with this.