Hello, Thank you for using JustAnswer.com, my name is ***** ***** I will be happy to assist you with your concern today. Just seeing if you still need assistance with this problem? Thanks, Joe
The biggest problem is "cost effective" that is only going to be steel, stainless, aluminum and titaninum would all work but cost will be 2-3x more +.
Your best option is sticking with steel, 250 lbs is not that much of a load and would handle it just fine with a good welder. If you need any further assistance just let me know.